Togainu no Chi – 02

by psgels, posted in Autumn 2010 Kaleidoscope



Ah, you know what? The World God Only Knows is hereby dropped. I thought about it a bit more yesterday, and realized something here:
– Panty and Stocking pokes fun at cute girls and American cartoons. It’s characters are thin, but it is a better comedy and parody than TWGOK.
– Squid Girl may not be a parody, but it’s still a much better comedy than TWGOK and its entire cast is far more down to earth and likable than Elcea.
– Milky Holmes has a great time taking the piss out of moe shows and the detective genre, and is also a far better comedy and parody than TWGOK.
– Kuragehime has a cliched premise, and yet it’s a far fresher and better comedy than TWGOK.
– When you look at the series that are carried over from previous seasons, you have Marie&Gali 2, which again with its creativity is far a better comedy and parody than TWGOK.

I didn’t realize this back on Wednesday, but damn: that show is redundant.

As an alternative, I’ve been considering Togainu no Chi and Otome Youkai Zakuro. Even though Togainu no Chi is much less well produced, it does have the potential that I don’t feel at Otome Youkai Zakuro. Until that changes, I’m interested enough in covering this series. This episode still was pretty poorly produced and acted, but the script was pretty solid, providing some much needed introductions and a much more varied cast. Mystery does remain one of my favourite genres, and this episode, unlike the first, had me intrigued.

It’s clear that the lead couple is gay at this point, but that was not one of my worries for this series. Instead, the bad bishie series are just like the bad moe series, in which they have this really weird and unnatural way in which they portray their characters. These are the series like Hanasakeru Seishounen and Miracle train, in which the characters act like a bunch of catalog models, or how everyone and his dog is suddenly gay. Most of this can be blamed on bad actors, who try way too hard to catch attention. Togainu no Chi has a few of those, but it’s not the entire cast here. This episode showed that the main couple knows how to at least be a bit subtle, That guy in the bar kept hopping back and forth between hammy and reserved, though that kid that was introduced in this episode is trying way too hard.

If a bunch of characters are gay, but well portrayed, I have no problems with them. Just in the same that moe girls get really annoying when they only try to pander to their audience without doing anything more. But really… that dog. I’m not really sure what to think about him…
Rating: * (Good)

Densetsu no Yuusha no Densetsu – 16

by psgels, posted in Densetsu no Yuusha no Densetsu



Recap. And not a good one either: most of it was told from the perspective of Ferris’ sister, so we had to endure a really annoying voice-over throughout this entire episode. Only the final part was amusing, when they tried to tally the amount of dango that Ferris has consumed throughout the series. At least that was creative.

Still, there are just nine episodes left. Withthat, I really am going to have to compare this to Koukaku no Regios: that too had a lot of potential for its storyline. It was built around a concept that was possibly even more interesting than Denyuuden’s, and yet for most of its airtime it just kept focusing on a bloody love triangle that went nowhere: out of everything that it could have chosen to focus on, it chose the most boring part, leaving the rest of the story as a giant rushed mess. That’s what I’m starting to fear that Denyuuden will turn into: I am really willing to believe that this series gets really awesome in its second half and all, but I’m not sure whether the anime creators also believe this. We’re talking about the same guy who wrote the adaptation of Kurogane no Linebarrels here… Will 9 episodes really be enough?
Rating: — (Lacking)

Shiki – 12

by psgels, posted in Shiki



It’s taken three weeks, but it’s worth the wait. This episode was mostly one that was delaying the inevitable, but it did so really well, with the same atmosphere that made the first half so good.

The focus surprisingly fell on Kaori and Akira, especially in the second half, since Natsuno was too busy dying and his father was being an asshole. Still, I thought that Natsuno might have tried to escape the Shiki, but to me that seems like it’s going to be Toshio and Seishin’s role. Throughout this episode, Natsuno focused more and more on getting Tooru back, and in the end he seemed to have just accepted that he’s going to be a vampire. Speaking of which… what the heck happened to Masao?

But those vampires are really shrewd: they systematically aim to disable parts of the village, they take over the entire village council, so nothing will go outside the village, they try to stop anyone who tries to go to Toshi’s house, and they’re really thinking of exterminating the entire village.

On a side-note: is the manga actually finished at this point? If not, then we’re having a potential pitfall here, because this is just one of those stories that would suck if it were cut off in the middle (pun not intended). Of course, the novel has an ending, and I really hope that the creators manage to blend in this ending well enough with the manga’s storyline. That really seems much more complicated than simply adapting a straight-forward manga story.
Rating: ** (Excellent)
OP: Better visuals, but the song isn’t as good as the first.
ED: This one’s really good, though: haunting soundtrack, beautiful visuals. Much better than the first ED.

Kuragehime – 01

by psgels, posted in Kuragehime



Ah, first impressions for those really late airing Noitamina shows are pointless. Over the course of 2009 and 2010, there has been only one Noitamina series that I didn’t blog: Nodame Cantabile’s Final arc. Apart from that, it really evolved into a top-notch time-slot over the past two years, in which just about every premise was creative, well thought out and varied. The sea creatures are really top notch this season.

I was looking forward to this series less than usual, though, but that all laid in the premise, which was full of things that are usually horribly abused in anime. While it’s true that this is the first series about fujoshi, series that focus on otaku are a dime a dozen, and I’ve really found that those shows, instead of trying to portray otaku, they instead try to glorify being an otaku way too much. Considering myself not really an otaku, there really have been very few otaku shows that I ended up liking. The same goes for cross-dressing: a lot of anime cross dressers are turned into some kind of fetish, or are just completely pointless in the series they’re in.

Still, my fears were completely wrong. Kuragehime is a series that’s full of life, and the comedy isn’t just funny: it plays around with a lot of other emotions. Basically, what I wanted to see in this episode was more than just a bunch of random jokes, but also a lot of character. This episode had its bits of drama, which really convinced me that this series will be more than just a bunch of random laughs. It introduced the lead character well, showing that it won’t have paper thin characters, and due to its slice of life nature, it can just stop at any random moment, avoiding Noitamina’s biggest weakness: its short length.

The thing I liked the most about this episode was its energy, though. It’s also really well directed, which always is a big plus. On top of that, I also loved how nonchalantly the creators introduced the cross-dresser in this episode. Most cross-dressers try not to get found out or something, but this guy just didn’t seem to care. I love how he is completely unlike any other anime character I’ve seen: straight-forward as hell, grown up, nonchalant, and someone who actually looks like he has a normal sex life. Really, since it seems like only 1% of all major characters in anime aren’t virgins, this really is a very potentially interesting guy.
Rating: ** (Excellent)
OP: Hollywood classics? Awesome!
ED: Interesting kid theme. A pretty nice song as well.

The World God Only Knows – 02

by psgels, posted in Autumn 2010 Kaleidoscope



Okay, so this one will be blogged, mostly based on how many people were looking forward to it. I’m going to take your word for it that this is supposed to be a parody, rather than something that doesn’t know it’s using its cliches. Overall, this series has some similarities to Togainu no Chi: both are series based on very popular franchises. Both weren’t the best at adaptations and both have rather bad directors. In TWGOK’s case, it’s been saddled with Shigehito Takayanagi, the guy behind Hime-Sama Goyoujin, a series whose entire premise was nothing but stupidity. You can really see those influences in Elcea, or was she also such a moe blob in the manga?

Still, the reason why I chose this series over Togainu no Chi is that it does have some decent characterizations. The main character is far from your average lead character and I’m expecting that this will continue on for the entire series. I especially want to see this series pulling off its female characters correctly, instead of making this into yet another series in which the lead characters makes a bunch of stereotypes fall for him. The twist at the end of this episode was a good start, but far from enough. A big problem is that there’s also no continuity: one moment there’s a hole in the house, the next moment that hole is gone. That stands out especially after a series like Squid Girl did this right.

Parodies are my favourite genre in anime comedies. To me, what constitutes a great parody is a series whose entire premise is made around making fun its subject material, and exploiting its flaws. With its premise, TWGOK made a good start, but at the same time I feel like it plays too many things straight, again, especially with Elcea. I really hope that her stupidity will be used to prove a point in the near future, because the cooking scenes, the scenes in which the classmates act like a bunch of dogs over the hot girl near the lead character, and the scenes in which Elcea immediately believes that sisters and brothers should bathe together: those aren’t parodies, they’re overused cliches and stereotypes that plague the moe genre. Obviously, if this series keeps that going on for too long, I’m going to switch over to Togainu no Chi or even Index if that too turns out to be a disaster.
Rating: (Enjoyable)

OVA Impressions: Tales of Symphonia – 07

by psgels, posted in OVA Impressions, Tales of Symphonia



As someone who played the original game, I am really happy with this episode: the creators did a wonderful job on it. Yeah, sure, it wasn’t 100% faithful, and a lot of the minor parts were cut away, but who cares! This episode really delivered where it should have, and it did especially Sheena justice.

Sheena’s story really took up the main focus of this episode, and I’m really glad to see that the creators of the anime realized that it’s indeed the characters who made the original game so good, rather than its typical story. I also love how much of a bigger role Corrine had here: it even appeared in front of Lloyd, to make him trust Sheena: he never did that in the game. The anime also put a lot more focus on the parallel between Sheena’s two attempts to summon a pact with Volt. The actual fight with Volt was done better in the game, but everything around it was actually way superior in the anime in my opinion.

It’s also interesting to see that the anime creators decided to reveal Lloyd’s father this early here. To come with a bit of a comparison: in the game we’re still on the first disk. Yuan only exposes Kratos, halfway through the second disk. Still, they really didn’t have any choice here, with the really shallow way that they’ve been foreshadowing it. That really was something at which the game was better. But at the same time, the revelation in the anime also really packed a punch: it was well timed and worked really well as a cliff-hanger at the end of this episode.

This is something subtle, but I also love what the creators did with Raine’s powers: in the games she already was one of the best characters in terms of combat, but they really made her kick ass beyond belief here: able to block Volt’s rays for several minutes, and while some of the other characters struggle to just slay one dragon, she blasts an entire army away. On top of that, I also really love the way that the creators found in order to reveal that she’s actually a half-elf: it both showed Regal’s intelligence, and also pretty much enabled that Pope to remain out of the storyline here. It’s much more subtle here, and I like it a lot more than in the games.

There is one part about this episode that I didn’t like, though: it’s the portrayal of Lloyd: he just doesn’t feel like a worthy main character here. In the game, he also had his flaws, but at the same time he was the one who pulled the rest of the characters along with him: he was impulsive, but resolute and that allowed everyone to move forward. The others in the meantime were the ones who provided him with advice when he was having a hard time. That latter is too much overstated in the anime: he just gets pulled around, he is a bit of a whiny brat, especially at the time when Yuan proposed an alliance. He just isn’t the leader here, which on the other hand isn’t so bad, because the rest of the cast is that awesome.
OVA Episode Rating: 8.75/10

OVA Impressions: Tamayura – 02

by psgels, posted in OVA Impressions



I didn’t check out the second episode of Tamayura immediately, because I wasn’t really that motivated after its disappointing first episode. Still, on Firechick’s recommendations I did end up giving it a whirl, and I’m glad I did: Tamayura’s second episode is much better than its first. This OVA really redeems itself here.

To me, a good slice of life series is one who fleshes out its characters well. A great one actually manages to use them well. I realize that this OVA still remains in the shadow of Windy Tales, but this episode really was more than just a bunch of random girls talking. Despite being slice of life, it tried to put a lot into just 20 minutes, and instead of animating a bunch of random events, it instead explored the lead characters’ passion for photography, showing how she’s always trying to get a good shot, how things relate to her past, along with the person she looks up to. Oh, and THANK GOD the whistle girl actually knows how to speak.

I still have a bit of a problem with the way in which cats are portrayed as moe blobs, though. I’m not sure, but my guess is that Azumanga Daioh once started simplifying these cats (or at least popularized it), and ever since it seems like everyone and his dog has been drawing these cats in blob-like ways, making them much less interesting than real cats. On top of that, the characters still rely a bit too much on their quirks at times, but the dialogue was well written for once, and really makes up for this.
OVA Episode Rating: 8/10

OVA Impressions: Yozakura Quartet – Hoshi no Umi – 01

by psgels, posted in OVA Impressions, Yozakura Quartet - Hoshi no Umi




Please, someone. Confirm that Yozakura Quartet’s OVA is going to be a long one. I mean, seriously: this is way too awesome to just end in three episodes. This was meant to be the real adaptation, faithful to the manga. There is no way that the manga is this small, right? I mean, that Supernatural OVA of Madhouse also has 22 episodes. There is no reason why this shouldn’t be possible for Yozakura Quartet as well, and it’s not like this episode felt rushed in any way. Right?

Let’s start with the animation, which is absolutely fantastic: there are no still frames whatsoever. Most of this episode was build up and slice of life, but even there the animation was consistently fluid and expressive. And then the action-scenes came, at the second half of the episode, and they were even better. If only because of those scenes, this OVA NEEDS to be watched.

As for the story… I really don’t know how the TV-series managed to screw things up this badly. I mean, it’s not like they had a bad director here: it was the director of Red Garden, Kurenai and Rozen Maiden: he really could have pulled this off. Instead, we got a generic shounen series that become boring after just one episode. This episode was much, much better. It knows that its premise around superpowerful teenagers is a bit bland, so it spends most of its time fleshing these people out.

They’re really helped by the animation here, but even there I feel like I’ve gotten a much better picture of the characters than with the TV-series, and in any case they’re a lot more likable now, despite the fact that it introduced another love triangle. It is a bit boring at times, especially when you don’t like teenagers, but it formed a very good base for the final parts of the episode, and the rest of the OVA.

The action was both fun, exciting and brutal. I love how the creators weren’t afraid to insert some humour, turning a bunch of stereotypical bank robbers into a bunch of hilarious scapegoats (something I’ve noticed with very few other anime), and the strong art and animation really did a great job to swap the mood into a much darker atmosphere.
OVA Episode Rating: 8,75/10

Nurarihyon no Mago – 15

by psgels, posted in Nurarihyon no Mago



Okay, now it’s official: this series needs a second season. This episode was apparently also anime original, and yet it blended in really well with the story: I would not have guessed it. The way it detailed the scenario also is bound to be good for this series in the long term. However, at this rate we’re never going to be able to reach the good stuff at episode 25. Studio Deen’s policy around sequels is… a bit weird, though. I mean, they let Kyou Kara Maou go on for three seasons of 39 episodes (directed by Junji Nishimura, of all people as well), and yet Fruits Basket just never went beyond 26 episodes, despite the huge amounts of manga still left.

Overall, I liked some of the ideas in this episode: I like how Gyuki’s subordinates actually managed to track down one of those evil youkai, who on his turn was trying to destroy all kinds of statues in an attempt to destroy some of the defences of the Nura clan, as well as trying to piss them off. On the meantime, you see that the gate that was destroyed gets immediately rebuilt, and a grave has been put up for the youkai that died in the previous episode. This episode didn’t particularly develop any plot or characters, but it made the setting a lot more solid with these subtle details.

As for the rest of the episode, it was average. Rikuo’s classmates are getting better, but they still are not the most exciting to watch. It also was a typical building up episode. This episode had a neat atmosphere, though it still nowhere is where it needs to be.
Rating: * (Good)

Shinryaku! Ika-Musume – 02

by psgels, posted in Shinryaku! Ika Musume



As for the series I’m not going to blog:
– Hakuouki ultimately remains cheesy and boring.
– Yosuga no Sora has actually some decent drama, but at the same time it also tries way too hard to be a harem.
– I’ve also decided not to blog Otome Youkai Zakuro, despite seriously considering this. In the end, I really could not feel any potential from it. It did well in showing the pasts of the different characters at such an early stage, but the second episode was pretty shallow in terms of its message about peaceful coexistence, and too many of the characters are simple stereotypes. The first episode really was excellent, but I fail to see whether the creators can add anything more than what was shown in these first two episodes.

In any case, I’m not yet 100 percent sure whether or not I’m going to continue blogging Squid Girl: if Kuragehime turns out awesome it will probably be swapped out. But I really wanted to try my hands again on blogging a pure comedy. I really don’t blog these kinds of shows often, and there are two basic reasons for that:
1. With most comedies, it’s impossible to predict whether they will remain fresh and funny through their entire airtime.
2. Quite a few of the good comedies are impossible for me to write about on a weekly basis. To take an example, one of my favourite comedies of 2010 is Gag Manga Biyori +. It was awesome in its hyperactive delivery, but I would have gone absolutely crazy, trying to come up with something to write for every single week.

Squid Girl has been the first pure comedy that fell in neither of those points since GA Geijutsuka Art Design Class, and I really want to give it a whirl. I’m really confident that this is a series that will remain funny for at least thirteen episodes: all of the jokes so far have been fresh and diverse. This series never bothered to repeat itself so far, and that’s a great sign. Usually you see great comedies that dull in after a hilarious first episode (take Otome Youkai Zakuro, whose second episode was significantly less funny than its first, even though it’s not a full comedy), but Squid Girl’s second episode was just as fun to watch as the first.

On top of that, the characterization is also pretty good here. The characters here aren’t a bunch of walking stereotypes: instead they are a bunch of normal people with some weird personality traits here and there: they’re all colourful, but they also know how to act normally. The titular Squid Girl meanwhile is very dynamic and lovable with her innocent curiosity. The way the creators have animated her also really brings her to life. Compare that to Panty and Stocking, in which the characters try way too hard to follow their own stereotype so that nothing else remains.

Anyway, about this episode: it was about half an introduction of two new characters (a life guard and one of Eiko’s classmates). Especially that life guard turned out to be a very good straight man for Squid Girl; he treats his job seriously, but not too seriously, like what many characters in his place end up doing, preventing his job from turning into some boring caricature.

The best jokes came from Squid Girl, though. My favourite parts in this episode were the point in which she tried to blow out the candles on her birthday cake, and the scene in which she realized that she forgot how to swim. I like how this series did well in showing her get accustomed to human culture, on top of portraying her like a little kid who’s trying to heckle people whenever she gets bored.

Diomedea is far from my favourite production company; heck, the best thing they made before this season was Kodomo no Jikan and that was about the only decent series I’ve ever seen from them. But you know what, in a season in which a studio like Madhouse has put out its worst performance in all of the five years that I’ve been blogging, I’m really wondering how they’ll pull this one off. So far at least, they’ve really succeeded in breathing life into Squid Girl, making it a very good adaptation (from the perspective of someone who has not read the original, of course).

Oh, and I also love how that hole that Squid Girl blew into the wall during the last episode is still there. Points for continuity.
Rating: ** (Excellent)