Winter 2020 Summary: Week 6

Mario: Next week, we will publish our seasonally State of the Season post, so remember to check in. Like Amun, real life stuff has eaten me alive but I still managed to keep up with current shows, and watched the Oscars yesterday. PARASITE wins. Honestly I’m still overwhelmed by that historic fact and honestly this is one of the best decisions Oscar has ever made. Parasite wins, and nothing else really matters anymore. But enough about Parasite and let’s dig in for anime time this week:

Somali to Mori no Kamisama – 05

Mario: Well, this easily is the best episode of Somali so far. The trick here is that the show does shake up its usual formula. I will start with the lesser success first. While the background designs of the various towns and locations the show displays have been its big strength, this episode is the first time it delves into the local custom of the town where Golem and Somali visits, thus making the settings feel lived-in. It also helps that later on when the group passes the forest, there are many fantasy animals (sand whales) that are pure feast in the eyes (albeit they are lacking in animation). But the real winner here is how it adds some urgency to the road trip of our main characters. We have a couple who are intriguing in their relationship (although the way the Harp girl keeps bringing up her love for her human companion gets repetitive at the end), and the fact that they are willing to harm Somali for their own gains. At least they have their own reasons to do so and I can see and understand that.

Rikei ga Koi ni Ochita no de Shoumei Shitemita – 06-07

Wooper: Both of these episodes were pretty meh, but I watched them in time for this post, so I might as well throw my thoughts into the digital abyss. The kissing experiment in episode 6 wasn’t a bad plot – I’ve seen that kind of barebones chemistry test pulled off before, but a show’s ability to do so hinges entirely on its cast. So far, RikeKoi has shown itself to be premise-driven, rather than character-driven, so the story didn’t quite fit. There was one brilliant mix of those two modes on display here, though: Yukimura’s promise to give Himuro “a kiss of the highest theoretical value.” Since the series is all about hot nerds trying to quantify love, that kind of declaration is both a strong relationship builder and a clever fulfillment of the show’s goals. As for episode 7, I found its reworking of fairy tales and folk stories to be its saving grace – everything else was pretty bad. When Himuro gets drunk and acts super lovey-dovey towards Yukimura, we don’t learn anything new about her (since it’s already clear that she likes him). But if the show puts a mathematical spin on stories like Cinderella and Kaguya-hime, that’s worth a chuckle or two.

Continue reading “Winter 2020 Summary: Week 6”

Winter 2020 Summary: Week 5

Mario: It’s time for another weekly summary. Geez, time sure flies fast. We’re nearly at the midseason already, can you believe that? Seasonal shows this week are… decent, I guess? Often the time this is a low period in seasonal anime, where anime studios rush and try their best to stay in schedule. We have a new show featured this week, and Lenlo is off to play volleyball rather than watching one. Enjoy! 

Oshi ga Budokan Ittekuretara Shinu – 04

Wooper: All this talk about Cham Jam “believing in their fans” and the glorification of unhealthy lifestyles lived in the name of idol appreciation are too much for this normalfriend to handle. I can tolerate sincere otaku fandom in small doses, but OshiBudo puts it front and center. This episode starts with a dramatic flashback to an encounter between Reo (during her time as a filler member of her previous idol group ‘Melty’) and Kumasa, her biggest fan. We’re talking “omit a key line during the conversation so that it can be revealed during the episode’s climactic moment” levels of drama, here. It ends up being a request for her to believe in him, which Reo passes on to Maina so that she’ll believe in her biggest supporter, Eripiyo. Meanwhile, Eripiyo is running herself ragged working three part-time jobs so she can buy dozens of Maina’s CDs and bump her numbers in the group’s popularity poll. That’s right, this week’s plot circles around to a popularity contest where supporting your favorite girl is viewed through an impossibly noble lens. The show still takes the odd dig at its dead broke otaku heroes here and there, but never with enough sharpness to puncture the balloon of idol worship at its core.

Kuutei Dragons – 02

Mario: After one third of the season done, I just remember a little show with no sub in which I enjoyed its premiere, Kuutei Dragon, so I decided to check the second one out, even with the 60 fps fan version (my first experience with 60 fpr and I still don’t get why people do that). Gotta say I still find this show charming. Whereas in Dorohedoro the characters share their chemistry by their love of food, in Kuutei Dragons it has only two things in mind: dragon hunter and dragon cuisine. The quest to enjoy this mystic beast’s meat is strong and it’s fun to watch. I also like its tongue-in-cheek humor and it has the same appeal of The Magnificent Kotobouki last year. I will check out the next episode, and if it proves to be as entertaining as the first two, then I’ll be happy to hop in for the ride.

Continue reading “Winter 2020 Summary: Week 5”

Magia Record – 04 [This Isn’t the Past]

I can certainly see the game mechanics in new episode: a whole new cast, a new rumor/ mystery, with Iroha’s quest to find Ui as a central plot. This is not a bad episode by any means, but I feel largely indifferent when the EP rolls. To Magia Record credits, the visual Shaft displays this week is a stunner. Magia Record looks on par with Madoka Magica, and this week the visual is benefited from the gorgeous art designs of last minute event. The story, however, is not as neat. While I really like the rumor behind it – the “Seance Shrine” can grant you the wish of meeting your lost one – and how it ties up with another urban legend of a woman who does everything to bring her dead husband back, it’s the new set of characters who doesn’t appear as memorable and the plot does meander at times. I’m talking about Yachiyo suddenly goes shopping in the middle of the quest and somehow that advances the story?

Continue reading “Magia Record – 04 [This Isn’t the Past]”

Kyokou Suiri – 03 [The Rumors of the Steel Lady]

Hey it’s me Mario who cover this eccentric little talky show this week. I have a confession first, I always have a thing for anime with excessive amount of dialogues, as long as they don’t try to sound like a broken talking dictionary or quote some philosophical nonsense (looking right at you Psycho Pass and Ghost in the Shells the movies), and I think that’s an important aspect to decide whether or not you are in for this particular ride. I mean, Kyokou Suiri is so gutsy that it features its entire second mystery in a single settings just by one character talks things out to another character. When you think of lengthy conversations in one setting, you might think it’s a dull experience but Kyokou Suiri (mostly) gets away with it. I will demonstrate this point by comparing the approach with other talky shows. For Monogatari series, whenever it gets to a lengthy chatter banter it utilizes its quirky visual to keep audience from feeling bored. For shows like OreGairu, it relies on characters gestures (usually a glance) to hint on their subtle inner feelings, for Kyokou Suiri it uses the flow of the conversation to suggest something deeper about its cases.
Continue reading “Kyokou Suiri – 03 [The Rumors of the Steel Lady]”

Winter 2020 Summary – Week 4

Mario: Apologize for posting this Weekly Summary a day late, as I was away last long weekend. Seasonal anime has passed its first 3 weeks now, which means they more or less show their true colors as this point and we writers more or less settle down on shows we will be watching through the rest of the season. 22/7 and OshiBudo have their first appearances in this column, but it remains to be seen whether they can hold our interest. Without further ado, read further to see what we say about them this week:

Haikyuu: To The Top! – Ep 3

Lenlo: Content wise, I think this was a good week for Haikyuu. It was nice to see Hinata figuring out what it is he lacks. Figuring out the smart way to play the game vs his previously purely instinctual methods, then slowly merging the two. He has yet to actually play, yet he is learning just by observing, which is something Hinata hasn’t really done till now. Being more focused on DOING. That said, it still feels like it lacks something visually. That being the sort of crisp visual style of previous seasons. It just sort of feels… flat? Like the spikes lack impact, the color doesn’t pop in places it feels like it should, and sometimes the faces feel off, etc. It’s still good, but coming off of previous Haikyuu seasons it feels a tad underwhelming. Granted, I watched all of those 2 weeks before the season started. So it’s a bit fresher for me than most others.

Oshi ga Budokan Ittekuretara Shinu – 2-3

Wooper: OshiBudo is approaching its central premise with less irony that the first episode led me to expect. Comedy is still a part of the show’s M.O., but the relationship between Eripiyo and Maina is disappointingly straightforward in its use of misunderstandings and unrequited longing. The aftermath of the tanzaku plot, for example, relied just as much on Maina’s love for her number one fan as it did on Eripiyo’s intense approach to idol fandom. That love has been teased as romantic a few times now, and while I think that development could take the show in an interesting direction, it’s probably just bait. There was a more credible bit of yuri between two Cham Jam members in episode 2, so who knows where the show is willing to go? Hopefully it keeps creating humorous setups, no matter what tone it settles on. Eripiyo’s shampoo-related tanzaku flying into view as her “fan letters” were scattered to the wind comes to mind as the comedic bar the show ought to be shooting for. If it continues to skew in a less playful, more sincere direction, though, I don’t know that I’ll make it through the whole cour.
Continue reading “Winter 2020 Summary – Week 4”

Winter 2020 Summary – Week 3

Mario: Welcome back to our Weekly Summary Column, I am the new host for this season, Mario. After a frantic first impression period, we are getting more stabilize now and starting to settle on our weekly offerings. I still need to catch up with leftovers from last season such as Blade of the Immortals and Babylon (yep, that Whore of Babylon) and maybe some other shows this season like 22/7, but that’ll be for the next post. Enjoy the roundup and tell me which shows you are following this season or even which shows you want us to cover here. We’ll take that into consideration.

ID:INVADED – 2-4

Wooper: ID:Invaded is my pet show of the season (not to be mistaken with my Pet show of the season). It’s not a critical darling like Eizouken or a surprise hit like Somali, but its high-concept procedural story and unconventional character designs have led me to favor it above most of this winter’s offerings. The plot: brilliant detective Sakaido solves his cases by entering the subconscious of serial killers, rendered as fractured, perilous mindscapes which he must navigate to uncover their identities. One of the things I appreciate most about Invaded is that, despite the magnitude of its premise, the characters aren’t swallowed by it. They have existing workplace relationships and personal histories, even if they’re not the focus of the show. Sakaido’s relationships with the more traditional cops and analysts on his team provide a nice foundation for his bloody backstory, which becomes clear in episode 3. After we learn what horrors he’s experienced, the show begins to demonstrate the influence and the existential detachment that comes from diving into people’s unconscious minds. The show is too verbose at times, and not every subconscious world is as interesting or well-designed as the last, but it has me intrigued enough to consider it a priority watch each week.

Somali to Mori no Kamisama – 2

Mario: I consider Somali episode 2 better than the first one (the premiere has a clumsy exposition part that nearly turns me off for good). The second episode has our Golem and Somali meeting other casts, so we both learn more about the world, and see how the chemistry between them all play out. The end of the episode also reveals more about Golem’s health and that adds to some urgency in regards to their journey. Golem and Somali also has a solid relationship where they grow fond of each other. But saying all that, I still can’t fully embrace the show and I do feel it loses its steam even after just 2 episodes. The fact that Somali is human could pose a potential threat given other beings are likely to consume her should they know – and I think the show will go there, but for now, we don’t sense any of that danger anywhere. And I know I just mentioned about the “urgency” but in truth, I don’t feel any sense of “hurry” at all. If I have to put my finger on why I’m still skeptical about the show, I’d say that its formula is too safe and predictable for now that it never full grasp me. Shake things up a bit would do the show better, I reckon.

Continue reading “Winter 2020 Summary – Week 3”

The Case Files of Jeweler Richard – 02 [The Ruby’s Truth]

Welcome to Jeweler Richard, one of the two shows that Amun and me are going to take turn to blog each week. For me, I find it interesting to see the varied opinions between me and him on the same shows. This episode, in particular, divides us. Amun hates it but I find it decent – not on par with the premiere, but still very decent. Granted, I can see some issues this week, most notably the case that has little to do with Richard’s appraisal skills. The jewelry in question this week is the pigeon-blood ruby, known for its namesake color. Mami the client wants to know whether or not the ruby had been heated, but it’s increasingly clear that there’s something else that she wants. In terms of the progression regarding that ruby case, it is all over the place at best. Suddenly out of nowhere, her fiancee appears to info-dump about Mami’s backstory – and the thing was he’a never that important a role to begin with. She uses a fake name whose we soon find out is the name of her past’s flame. On the positive notes, Jeweler Richard the show has this fascinating view about women’s lives – Seigi’s grandma last week and Mami this week show how these women struggling with the roles they were expected to perform and their real desires. For that I’m willing to look aside all its shaky elements for now.

Continue reading “The Case Files of Jeweler Richard – 02 [The Ruby’s Truth]”

Magia Record – 02/03 [It’s Proof of the End of a Friendship/ Sorry For Making You My Friend]

Magia Record sure has a pretty big hurdle to pass: for everything it does there will be a comparison to its original – which for me is both fair and unfair at the same time. Every product should be judged on its own merits, but Magia Record gains its attention for being a Madoka’s spinoff (or else no one would be willing to watch it), so that it’s a show’s responsibility to justify why it needs to be here in the first place. As far as the first three episodes concern, they (mostly) manage to stand on its own terms. It keeps the spirits of the original – the sense of there is something wrong in this world is clear, and several mysteries remain in support for that uneasy feeling. What is the deal with this Kamihama city, for example? The magical girls there are more powerful than the rest, the witches don’t have Greed seed (which implies that they might not be witches in the first place), and Kyubei can’t enter the area. Then we have the mystery regarding Iroha’s little sister Ui, as she dreams of her sisters’ best friends while she was living in the hospital. What did she wish for that single handedly wipe out Ui’s existence from everyone’s memory, Kyubei included? I’m sure that wish is not for the faint of heart.

Continue reading “Magia Record – 02/03 [It’s Proof of the End of a Friendship/ Sorry For Making You My Friend]”

Winter 2020 Anime Coverage & First Episode Awards

Mario: Hey folks, welcome to the brand new decade of anime. Winter season is usually the quiet time for anime, and this edition doesn’t seem to break that pattern. Wish-fulfillment isekai and jerky CG idol shows are still going strong to remind us that the fruits of the last decade aren’t truly gone. And while this season might be lacking in terms of truly elite premieres (I can count only Eizouken and Haikyuu), there are many promising lower-tier shows that could manage to become sleeper hits. Without further ado, I’m pleased to present our coverage for this season:

WINTER 2020 BLOGGING SCHEDULE

Mario: Magia Record – The Case Files of Jeweler Richard/Kyoko Suiri*

Lenlo:  Eizouken ni Wa te wo Dasu na! – Runway de Waratte – Throwback Thursday: Neon Genesis Evangelion

Wooper: Chihayafuru 3 (carry-over) – Dorohedoro

Amun: My Hero Academia 4 (carry-over) – The Case Files of Jeweler Richard/ Kyoko Suiri*

As you can see, this season we writers are trying something a bit different with the blogging. In true “multi-author” spirit, Amun and I will take turns covering Jeweler Richard and Kyoko Suiri each week. Expect an array of different opinions from each of us. In addition, it’s my intention to keep the Weekly Summary running, which means that some shows that aren’t in our blogging list might find their way over there.

FIRST EPISODE AWARDS

Best First Episode
(The Death Note Award)

EIZOUKEN NI WA TE WO DASU NA!

Likely Spent All Their Efforts on the First Episode
(The Kyoukai No Kanata Award)

ID:INVADED

Best Animation
(The Samurai Champloo Award)

EIZOUKEN NI WA TE WO DASU NA!


Season Sleeper
(The Gargantia Award)

RUNWAY DE WARATTE

Worst First Episode
(The Bleach Award)

PLUNDERER

Exceeded Expectations
(The Hyouka Award)

THE CASE FILES OF JEWELER RICHARD


Most Disappointing First Episode
(The Berserk Award)

PET

Best Continuation
(The Natsume Book of Friends Award)

HAIKYUU!! TO THE TOP

Best Background Art
(Made in Abyss Award)

DOROHEDORO

Some Quick First Impressions: Kuutei Dragons, ARP Backstage Pass and Plunderer

Kuutei Dragons

Short Synopsis: A ship of vagabonds hunts dragon for food and money.

Amun’s review:

This is a terribly hard anime to find, but if you can find it….it’s not really worth your time.  I’m even willing to forgive whoever valiantly tried to sub it, despite having a mastery of neither the English nor Japanese language.  No, the real problem here is the jerky 3D animation and the thinly veiled analogies to whale hunting which don’t really translate well to steampunk/dragon fantasy.  Hopefully the staff will learn enough here to become full fledged animators in their own time – this just isn’t going to be their breakout project. With ironically flat characters (except their thighs for some reason) and subpar visuals, I think everyone can safely pass on this.  

Potential: 10% 

Mario’s review:

Unlike Amun, I can say I have a good tolerance with full CG shows, well… some of them. I can’t be bothered with the new clunky CG in Berserk or Ajin for example (the latter is from the same company of Kuutei Dragon), but I did enjoy shows like The Magnificent Kotobuki last year or Ronja the Robber’s Daughter. So, which spectrum does Kuutei Dragon fall into? I’m happy to report that I enjoy the whole lot of it (well, terrible sub aside). The CG character models look bland, true, but I got used to that very quickly. The CG fares better when it concerns the ship and the dragon models. Add to that, I like the worldbuilding of dragon hunting just for food, like a good mix of whale hunting and the love for delicious food. Its easy humor and tongue-in-cheek nature reminds me a good deal of Magnificent Kotobuki, and if that is the case, I know I am in a good company. Just give me a decent enough subtitles.  

Potential: 50%

 

ARP Backstage Pass

Short Synopsis: A behind-the-scenes look at a male idol group.

Mario’s review:

Right off the bat, the CG live performance stands out like a sore thumb and things only get worse from there. This is apparently based on a real (maybe virtual?) band, and all we see in this episode is a little bit of them in school. It functions more like a promotion for that art school and the ARP director (whatever ARP means) than putting effort to tell any story. To give this show some credit, the dance routine of one team member is surprisingly inspiring, and it is in traditional hand drawn style. When it switches to the CG (especially the after credit where it doesn’t need to be) it becomes soulless. Soulless is pretty much how I’d describe this show.

Potential: Soulless

 

Plunderer

Short Synopsis: A girl walks around in search of the Chosen One.

Mario’s review:

Just like what Amun said back in the season preview, Plunderer is indeed terrible. The concept of a world run by “counts” is not a bad idea, but they mishandle everything else completely. There is not a single likeable character, and the show goes borderline offensive with its sexual harassment jokes and cringe worthy humor. Girls are treated like dirt in this show, especially the main girl who is so dumb that despite living in that world she doesn’t know one bit about the rules – how does she survive until now? Congrats Plunderer, you beat Ishizoku Reviewers as the worst premiere of this season.

Potential: TERRIBLE. HORRIBLE