Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 10

My Villain (Hero) Academia (S5) – 22

Amun: After last week’s controversial and personally disappointing episode, MVA is back on track. For some reason, it wasn’t clear until this week that these episodes are going to be origin stories for each league member – I think the other problems with Toga’s story overshadowed the mirrored “hero-origin” format: single enemy, going beyond one’s limits to overcome past problems, power of friendship, etc. Twice’s origin hit the right notes, largely due to his built-in humour and the fact that his quirk is pretty important to smoothing out plot problems. Now that I’ve understood what’s happening with My Villain Academy, I appreciate what the writers are going for. Some major plot developments look to be brewing – we know Shigaraki is connected to All-Might’s teacher, the previous One-For-All (I think we were told he’s her son?), and Dabi is being strangely built up as a character – he really didn’t get that much screen time in past seasons. With the earlier drauma from the Todoroki family – and given that one other major league member is a Nomos – I half suspect he’s the dead brother (he’s a zombie, uses fire, etc). Why else spend the first half of this season setting that up? That twist might be a bit on the nose, but this is MHA we’re talking about. Regardless, I’m happy to see our season’s major franchise back on track.

Heion Sedai no Idaten-tachi – 7

Wooper: I found this to be Idaten’s least daring episode to date, perhaps owing to the fact that all the demigods’ plans went off without a hitch. Ysley put the church of Sarabael under his thumb just by dangling Paula in front of their faces, and Rin/Hayato’s invasion of the Zoble Empire was the very picture of one-sided carnage. Some of the shots of the two of them working together were significant in terms of their evolving master/student relationship, but I don’t think we saw anything in episode 7 that we hadn’t seen before (unless you count Sarabael’s tower-heavy architecture, which kinda reminded me of Utena). The big surprise here was supposed to be the emergence of a self-styled Emperor from within the demon camp, but isn’t he just going to get his shit pushed in like everyone else? This show has only four weeks left, being a noitaminA entry, but even that number almost seems like too much, given the Saitama-sized gap that exists between Rin and everyone else. Just throw her into a string of fight scenes and dispatch all the villains one by one so we can get back to the strangeness and psychedelia of the early episodes, please.

Love Live! Superstar!! – 5

Wooper: One of the things that most impresses me about this show is how consistently it generates fun and friendly banter between its female characters. Keke and Sumire bickered with each other all throughout this episode, but I never tired of listening to them bust out variations on their catchphrases or proclaim the supremacy of their favorite artistic field (School Idols vs. Show Business). Whether they were daring each other to practice in sweltering temperatures or thumb wrestling to secure a solo bed during an overnight trip, their antics kept me engaged in each of their scenes. This week’s trip to Kozushima was important for Kanon and Chisato, too, allowing them to take on individual challenges before their imminent reunion (whereupon Chisato will likely join the idol group). What’s interesting to me is that I don’t know which of them will have more success: Kanon with her lyrics or Chi-chan with her dancing. Regardless of who fails and who triumphs, Superstar has already succeeded in shifting Chisato’s focus so that it lines up with the other girls. She might win her competition and prove to herself that she can be a part of both worlds, or lose but remain satisfied because she’s found a different calling. This is all good stuff – now to wait for Liella to gain some ground on Sunny Passion in anticipation of the finale!

Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 9

Kaizoku Oujo – 3-4

Wooper: This is one good-looking anime series. It’s got backgrounds that make you want to travel to the places that inspired them, character designs that make you hungry for details about each person on screen, and combat that showcases power and agility rather than flashbacks and hidden techniques. Episode 3 was the pinnacle of those last two traits, pitting several members of Team Fena against a crew of female pirates in a fight scene so smooth it nearly had me salivating. The Italian architecture of fictional city Bar-Baral served as an excellent backdrop for all the slicing and shooting on display, and montages of the characters’ sightseeing ensured there was plenty of eye candy during quieter moments. Not that Kaizoku Oujo turns down the volume very often – its nonstop comic relief is one of its only issues – but it’s a visual marvel at nearly all points. As Fena and company travel from place to place in search of info about her glass MacGuffin, the show is raising up striking antagonists and painting a picture of its alternate history’s politics, creating more and more reasons to keep watching. There’s even a bit of romance brewing between Fena and Yukimaru, the latter of whom attracted the attention of a sexy glassworker this week. Not even Joan of Arc’s name being invoked has me concerned about the show’s viability – bring on the next episode!

My Villain Academia (S5) – 21

Amun: This week’s My Hero Academia (or Villain Academia as this arc is called) has caused quite a stir – and not for good reasons. Debates between animators vs designed scenes aside, this episode….was a stinker. This overall season has been really odd – it’s a tale of two scales: the first half was a training exercise with no stakes and the second half has been a global conspiracy that threatens to upend society entirely. And if that wasn’t enough whiplash, we’re thrown a whole cast of characters, while following the training arc…of the bad guys? Now, on paper, that’s not a bad arc idea for a long running series. The issue lies in execution. I don’t even think this episode was that poorly written – I’m just missing all the characters I care about. Sure, I marginally care about the League of Villains – but the new Destro-whatever-meta-liberation-army nonsense? Not that interested. The elephant in the room on this one was the animation – it just wasn’t up to snuff. Judging from the outside drama, it looks like about half the frames were removed, which really hurt. You can feel the creative edits and last second bandaging that took place. This should have been a seminal episode for evolving quirks and Himiko’s break-out back-story. Instead, it’s a mess of pointing fingers and uncertainty as we head into the back half of this puzzling season.

Vanitas – 9

Amun: If My Hero Academia is a good idea with poor execution, Vanitas is an average idea with excellent execution. I have to give Vanitas complete kudos for knowing its strengths and sticking to them. This is not a complicated or terribly clever plot: these writers aren’t being intellectually taxed by any means. It’s the implementation – fight animations, world-building, or even the banter between Noe and Vanitas – that makes this show a treat. I love Vanitas’ overall self-awareness; this show trots out the expected troupes, then turns them on their heads. Case and point is our lovable, dogmatic Paladin, who is won over by Noe’s kindred idiocy – fantastic! The animation isn’t detracting (a common complaint for these non-franchise shows), the characters are loveable, the world is excellent – this is a certifiable fun show and a romping good time.

Re-Main – 6-7

Wooper: Spending a couple weeks away from Re-Main has put a big dent in my enthusiasm for the show. The first half of this doubleheader was a clear step down from everything that came before, but even yesterday’s character-focused installment left me feeling ambivalent about the series as a whole. I still remember the second episode’s promise to dive into the cast’s individual histories, and even though episode 7 continued that admirable trend, I couldn’t get into it. Maybe that’s because Jojima did too much explaining of his fractured relationship with his dad, or because the show over-clarified how Amihama’s sibling bond changed after his brother met Minato. That minor lack of nuance is something I know to expect from anime, though – my negative reaction to the previous week’s Re-Main probably just carried into this one. Episode 6 was a low point for a number of reasons, not least of which was the brittle animation (not a quality you want from a water-themed show), but what really did it in was the focus on the show’s least interesting character, Ushi. Whoever wrote this one had to lean on a false suicide scare just to inject some drama into the proceedings – that’s an episode-killer for me.

Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 8

Kaizoku Oujo – 1-2

Wooper: Kazuto Nakazawa’s new TV anime, a pre-industrial pirate/ninja mashup, is off to what I’d call a decent start. Its design sensibilities remind me of his last series, the overambitious B: The Beginning – thankfully, the similarities are merely stylistic in nature. Kaizoku Oujo is an honest-to-goodness adventure show, the likes of which we haven’t gotten from anime in some time, and its cast is full of colorful characters (as all good adventure casts should be). Fena Houtman is a serviceable protagonist, handling the transition from captive princess to Campbellian hero with a mix of grit and introspection, but it’s her band of boisterous Japanese pirates that commanded my attention during the double-length premiere. I can see them getting on my nerves before long, but assuming the show has plans to slow down and dig into their personal histories, I’ll eventually be free to enjoy their antics alongside strong character designs and fighting styles. The story hasn’t taken shape yet, so I’m hoping for some good standalone episodes in the coming weeks to take advantage of studio Bamboo’s varied backgrounds. “Hoping for” is the key phrase there, as confidence in a modern Nakazawa work requires plenty of hope, but I’m willing to follow along for now.

Shinigami Bocchan – 08

Amun: Shinigami Bocchan has been my dark horse of the season. With many of the other shows faltering, this adorable quiet romance has kept plugging away at the admittedly difficult problem of getting our Count Death a girlfriend. I’ve been very pleased with the witches developing into actual characters, and we’re starting to see the edges of the family structure. Episode 8 is probably the best outing yet, with a flashback to what our sad boi was like before Alice arrived. Two key lines from this episode also imply that Mother isn’t the cruel parent the OP makes her out to be: his younger brother (with a hilarious second complex) says that their mother hasn’t given up yet, and Rob says Alice was sent by the lady of the house. Why would an uncaring mother send in the only known “friend” to her son? Who also seems to have witch connections through her own mother? Methinks there’s more than meets the eye here – seems like Mother has plans of her own to solve this problem. Which likely will turn out to be the power of love (“He’s cursed to never love or be loved”) – a bit predictable, but it’ll be a pleasant journey nonetheless.

Continue reading “Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 8”

State of the Season – Summer 2021

Mario: This surely is one of the sparest seasons in recent memory. Ironically, with the current lockdown in my city, I managed to touch base with all the goods of this season in the last few days and truly attained the life of a shut-in (hey, it’s not that bad). There’s only one show that I consider a standout of the season so far, and even that show is divisive amongst the writers. On the whole, I’d say that this season serves as a perfect opportunity for all of us to slow down and catch up with our backlogs. Read on to find out what we think about the summer season at the halfway mark (and be sure to check out the new release of Fena: Pirate Princess, which is rolling out at the time of this writing).

What show are you enjoying that you’re not reviewing?

Wooper: Heion Sedai no Idaten-tachi. Its stylized violence and daring use of color combine to create a one-of-a-kind viewing experience. Even if the story is unlikely to go anywhere interesting, the episodes themselves are never boring, since the show restlessly experiments with its own presentation.

Lenlo: I’m rewatching Hajime no Ippo and that’s been a good time, but that’s about it. Nothing this season is really popping out or inspiring me, and with old favorites like MHA getting screwed over for their movies it’s just not a good time to be me.

Mario: It’s Sonny Boy & Heion Sedai no Idaten-tachi vs. the rest for me so far. We will talk more about Sonny Boy below, so allow me to sing Heion Sedai’s praises. For me, it’s a perfect marriage between the old style and the new. The slapstick nature, the simple character designs and even its premise bring you the feel of old Dragon Ball adventures, but the show updates it with vibrant colors and fast-forward tweaks when it comes to info-dumping. All that makes it a fun and memorable watch.

Amun: Mairimashita! Iruma-kun, Hamefura, and Slime Isekai are carrying this season for me.

Continue reading “State of the Season – Summer 2021”

Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 6

Love Live! Superstar!! – 1

Wooper: After holding out for a good eight years, this was my first time viewing a Love Live anime, and wouldn’t you know it, my cognitive functions are none the worse for wear. It did feel a bit like watching a commercial, but I’m so old and grumpy that the majority of anime gives me that same feeling. It was a well-made commercial at least, with some of the prettier backgrounds I’ve seen this season, full of springy greens and sakura pinks that somehow managed to coordinate themselves with main character Kanon’s orange hair. Kanon is the main reason I enjoyed the episode as much as I did – she’s occasionally moody and defiant, as befits her age, but she overcomes those emotions to help a new friend whose idol ambitions might otherwise be crushed. There was a real connection between the song of the week and Kanon, who authored it years ago but wasn’t able to perform it until now due to stage fright. The episode’s direction highlighted both her fear and her brash personality by mixing up its framing, putting her off to the side in some shots and front and center in others. Visuals, music, emotions – they all worked harmoniously in this premiere, so I’ll hope for the best and pick up Superstar as soon as it returns from its Olympic hiatus.

Heion Sedai no Idaten-tachi – 4

Wooper: Hot damn, this series is on a roll, at least in aesthetic terms. Background characters are still well-drawn, fight scenes are stuffed with flurried fists and elemental beams, and color design pushes the envelope but always manages to create a few standout moments per episode. This week my favorite sight was the shot of demigods Ysley and Paula walking on the seafloor to avoid detection from enemy submarines. Would a trip to the bottom of the ocean be as colorful as Idaten made it out to be? No way, but stylish exaggeration is the show’s bread and butter, and I’m all for it. The story is starting to take shape, as well, with the demons moving humans about the Earth like pawns on a chess board, and Ysley doing a fair bit of manipulation himself. The series’ primary concerns are still carnage and mayhem, as evidenced by the three showdowns promised in this week’s cliffhanger, but with Prontea’s introduction and Maou-sama receiving a new body, the cast is slowly getting beefed up in preparation for something bigger. If that future looks anything like the show’s present, I’ll gladly stick around to see it realized.

Re-Main – 5

Wooper: Re-Main is turning out to be the little sports anime that could, sort of like last year’s Taiso Samurai. That one ended up belly flopping in the second half, and there’s a very real chance that Re-Main could do the same, since they’re similarly mediocre at depicting their chosen sports. But they have the same strength, as well: telling offbeat stories to further our understanding of their characters. This episode’s oddity was the reveal that Eitarou had fabricated his past friendship with Minato, whose missing memories made it impossible for him to spot the other boy’s lies. Re-Main has continually surprised me by keeping Minato’s amnesia relevant from week to week, rather than using it as a one-and-done reset button, and this was one of its best applications yet. Frankly, I wish this story had been a little gayer than it was on the page – Eitarou strikes me as the type, and the methods he used to befriend his water polo idol seemed more than athletically driven, at least to me. In any case, their confrontation at the shrine featured some strong layouts, and their subsequent reconciliation was solidly written. Having cleared the landmine of Eitarou’s potential resignation, the team is still together – let’s hope their next match goes better than their recent 18-0 defeat.

Great Jahy – 02 [DROPPED]

Amun: My enthusiasm for the great Jahy proved short-lived. Truthfully, I haven’t even finished this episode – I gave up about halfway through. My issues: all the wrong lessons were learned from the spiritual predecessors of this show. Basically, the central character needs to be a demon in name only – there needs to be redeeming qualities and humanity present. Jahy is completely missing that – I do not like any of these characters, even remotely. This introduction of the previously abused underling, now living the high life does nothing for me. At least Dropkick my Devil was funny (and not really mean-spirited). Jahy is just…lacking an identity. It can’t even decide if the service should be type A or B…I’m done.

Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 5

Vanitas – 05

Amun: (Sorry, sorry, I know I’m not Armi). Vanitas this week was worth talking about – and how it’s faring as a vampire show overall. Vampires are a genre I’d love to see a resurgence after quite a few uneven showings in the last few years. The genre’s cornerstone – Hellsing – is unlikely to be replicated as the successors, like inferior offspring, fall into several traps: excessive brain-dead gore (Hellsing Ultimate), failed humour (Blood Lad), a confused zombie show (Shiki), or a monsters ensemble – which is not actually a vampire show at all (Kekkai Sensen, Monogatari series). Proper vampire shows are still around – Mars Red from last season was a decent attempt that tripped on its own feet halfway through. Vanitas so far has a great setup and a superlative twist – vampire and vampire hunter team up to defeat the threat…only it’s not a vampire hunter, it’s actually a vampire doctor. The bloodsuckers, so often the perpetrators, are the victims here – this isn’t human vs vampire, it’s a complicated world of humans helping/hurting vampires who are helping/hurting each other. That’s an excellent premise. How’s the execution? 5 episodes in, my verdict is: good! Noe is a surprisingly interesting viewer vehicle – he clearly has his own demons and is certainly marching to his own beat. Vanitas is what anti-heroes should be: not complete scum without a single redeeming quality, but a flawed person with good intentions and complicated motivations. The villain is sufficiently spooky and the supporting cast fleshes out well enough – I’m really quite pleased so far. I think this episode also had a great use of violence for a purpose instead of just for shock-value – you really feel Noe’s personal involvement with curse-bearers. Vampire shows are going to be a bit rough on the viewer, but that’s the nature of the genre, and I think so far – Vanitas has handled it excellently.

Continue reading “Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 5”

Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 4

My Hero Academia – 105

Amun: (Side note: reactions are too hard – I might do them again at some point). It has been a while since I wrote about My Hero Academia, so I thought I’d check in on Midoriya and the boys (no, that’s not a figure of speech, it’s pretty much just Midoriya, Todoroki, and Bakugo this season representing UA). Episode 105 – “The Hellish Todorki Family” – is an example of what I’m calling “sledgehammer precision painting.” What I mean by that – in any 13 episode anime, Todoroki Shoto’s character would have the subtlety of well…a sledgehammer. Over-talented, rich kid with daddy issues – wow, so brave. However, even a sledgehammer can paint fine lines if the canvas is the size of a skyscraper – MHA with its seemingly unlimited seasons has developed first-glance straightforward characters (Endeavour, you’re in there too) into an interesting story that grapples with real problems. I’m not saying it’s subtle – but it works given the huge body of work this anime’s produced. I think these depth-giving stories for the supporting cast is also important, since Midoriya’s quest to get stronger and fight worse villains isn’t going to keep us going for another hundred episodes. Also, props to Bakugo for getting Mapo Tofu – I love that stuff!

Continue reading “Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 4”

Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 3

Amun: Hello! I’m your new weekly summary host, Amun. I’m going to be trying a little something slightly new: adding reactions to each episode we watch for the week. So without further ado, how’s the season going so far?

Re-Main – 2

👏Wooper’s welcoming!👏

Wooper: There was no third episode of Re-Main yesterday due to a scheduling conflict with the British Open, though I doubt too many Western fans were put out by the change. This series is years behind modern hits like Haikyuu in terms of its obvious character types and occasionally jarring comedy. It’s still out here dangling a cute girl in front of its male lead for motivation like a 90s sports anime, for crying out loud. Re-Main doesn’t know that we’re living in 2021, but I wish I didn’t either, which might explain why I’m somewhat fond of it. The amnesiac protagonist trick might be an obvious ploy to create an audience surrogate, but Minato has a great attitude nonetheless. His fun-loving personality and desire to help others are balanced by self-doubt and resentment that people expect so much of him in the wake of his accident, creating a character (and a storyline) that are enjoyable to follow. The other water polo boys are much shallower by comparison, but the quick montage of their histories near the end of the episode read like the show’s promise to explore each of their motivations in turn. I doubt any of those explorations will match Minato’s, but as long as the attempt is wholehearted, it’ll fall nicely in line with Re-Main’s scrappy retro spirit.

Continue reading “Summer 2021 Weekly Summary – Week 3”

Summer 2021 First Impressions: D_Cide Traumerei, Deatte 5-byou de Battle, Night Head 2041

D_Cide Traumerei the Animation

Short Synopsis: Handsome fighter fights some hands.

Mario: I’m most forgiving of fully-3D shows compared to the rest of the writers here, so I tend to be in favor of Sanzigen’s products, no matter how off-putting they look. D_Cide looks solid as I’m in tune with its aesthetic, and occasionally its use of color looks impressive to me. What I’m not sold on at all is the story, as so far it’s nothing to speak of. The main character jumps between dreams and reality – an intriguing plot in its own right – but sadly the show uses it more as a plot device to bring him to battle with CG monsters. The only storytelling beat where I feel the show gets it right is when our protagonist practices kick-boxing before all this happens. That scene speaks to me as I can see his personality right there, making his grief for his brother’s passing part of his routine, while at the same time foreshadowing his ability at the end. His war cry of “KNOCKER UP” kills the vibe a tad bit, but as things stand I am willing to give the show a few more episodes.

Potential: 30%

Wooper: Of all the stupid battle-oriented CG anime I’ve sampled over the years, D_Cide is among the stupidest. To provide a bit of context, I can’t decide whether it’s better or worse than this season’s Scarlet Nexus, which was terrible in its own right. Everything from the main character’s scalene triangle earring to the female characters’ overwrought designs to the good guys’ combat titles (Knocker-ups) are dumb with a capital “D”. The only thing I liked about the story was the main character’s martial artistry, which provides some insight into how he processed his brother’s passing – taking his departed sibling’s passion and making it his own. That fighting style is carried into his Knocker-up form, allowing him to punch giant hand monsters right in their smug zipper mouths. Those scenes are about as nonsensical as they sound, and the show’s flirtation with dreams and portals will surely muddy the waters as D_Cide progresses. Between its strange mishmash of visual ideas and its relative lack of interest in character building, there’s not a lot here to hope for. When the best thing about an anime is the ten second piano/guitar lick at the start of the OP, you know it’s a skippable experience.

Potential: 10%

Deatte 5-byou de Battle

Short Synopsis: A lone gamer dies and is summoned to a Gantz-like world for a battle royale (I made it sound more interesting than it really is).

Lenlo: I don’t know if I like Deatte or if it’s just one of the least-bad things I’ve seen so far this season. Visually it’s a mess. Deatte can’t seem to figure out how people move, how objects interact with each other or that desks don’t just fall through people. Meanwhile the characters are about as shallow as you would expect from a “death battle with super powers” style anime. Maybe some fun will be had with our borderline autistic MC who has no emotions and can’t view the world as anything other than a game, but I doubt it. No, the only value in Deatte will come from how interesting it can make its battles. The MC’s power is actually rather clever and I think if utilized well it can lead to some fun mind games. There issue there though is that I have 0 faith in Deatte to be able to avoid bullshiting its own system. For now though I can at least give it the benefit of the doubt in this drought of a season, and listen to some… interesting (?) cat girl voicework along the way.

Potential: 10%

Mario: If there’s ever been a subgenre that I don’t give a damn about, it’s Death Games. The premise for these kinds of shows is simple: you need to clear several missions, or you’re dead. While they provide many fun twists and turns, they suffer in almost every other arena. The characters are cardboard cutouts. The story runs on game logic, and has plot holes and inconsistencies all over the place. The lead boy is charmless and even unlikeable. The same extends to the whole cast and even the cat girl who pushes the boundaries of annoying voicework. Deatte 5-byou is a good example of all the ways this subgenre can screw up. It’s a silly premise with an empty cast and mediocre production. No reason to revisit this one.

Potential: 5%

Night Head 2041

Short Synopsis: Psychics time travel to a futuristic post-WW3 city and go up against a team of cyberpunk super soldiers.

Armitage: Apart from having a title that can be easily mistaken for a hentai doujin, this show doesn’t do a whole lot more to stand out. Still, it’s just the absolute mediocrity of this season that had me getting some sort of enjoyment out of its runtime. The premise is right out of a 12-year-old’s fever dream but apparently the writer who came up with that storyline forgot to think about any characters who would carry said story. That’s why most of the characters end up feeling stiff CGI caricatures simply present to list out names and motivations of other characters, most of whom never even get introduced during the premiere. The writing in general is very obtuse and expository and might very well alienate its target audience. The one positive is definitely the setting. “That’s cool and all, but make it cyberpunk” seems to be the new narrative model of late when it comes to entertainment media but thankfully Night Head 2041 does seem to get the environmental ambiance right most of the time. The CGI while still very noticeable doesn’t look nearly as bad as Ex-Arm. So that’s… good. I guess?

Potential: 35%

Lenlo: Night Head is a weird show. Visually it’s all over the place. The CGI characters, as CGI does in Japan, look stiff and lifeless 90% of the time. Meanwhile the backgrounds and general aesthetic of the show look quite nice! The lighting and diffusion, backgrounds, some fun camera shots/movements that can’t easily be done in 2D. Night Head was clearly envisioned as 3D from the beginning and makes use of that but is limited by the CGI anime pipeline. On the story side of things I think it’s… fine? It’s basically the X-Men, which I’m down for. But I’m unfamiliar with author George Iida’s other works, so I don’t know how it will pan out. For now though I’m curious enough to give it a shot, if only to see what the director can do in his debut.

Potential: 20%

Summer 2021 First Impressions: Shiroi Suna no Aquatope, Tsuki ga Michibiku Isekai Douchuu, Meikyuu Black Company

Shiroi Suna no Aquatope

Short Synopsis: A failed idol and an overworked highschooler collide in a quiet, mystical…aquarium?

Mario: Ahh P.A. Works, how conflicted my love for you. Watching Aquatope, I have two conflicting trains of thoughts toward it: as the quality of the episode itself, and as an input towards the studio’s canon. As far as the former goes, they deliver an overall excellent episode. There’s an air of melancholy from the way the main character navigates this new world, or to be more exact, runs away from her own that I found believable, and the two main girls’ interaction so far sparkles with great chemistry. On top of that, it’s these side characters (don’t know if they reappear) that the main girl interacts with steal the scene they are in – special shoutout to the cheeky fortune teller. On the flip side, however, Aquatope has the same “feel” as P.A. Works other works, and the fact that most of their works start out strong, then crumble in the last half (last year’s Kamisama, the director’s last effort’s Irozuku just to name a few) doesn’t bring me much confidence in this. I’m afraid this is gonna be another case where there’s little plot to move forward, so the characters retreat to the variations of the same themes. Time will tell on that front, but my point remains that I keep my expectation reasonably medium so that it won’t let me down, hard, like their previous efforts.

Potential: 60%

Amun: I like most P.A. Works projects – well, more accurately, most of each P.A. Works project – and Aquatope is a welcome sight for sore isekai eyes this season.  This episode looked great – wonderful settings, great atmosphere, just a wholly enticing package.  I would be incredibly hopeful….except we just had Kamisama ni Natta Hi start exactly like this.  However, I’m seeing parallels to the more successful projects with the characters here – so far, it’s a pretty tight crew.  That’s good.  There’s also some mystical nonsense taking place – that’s bad.  Director Shinohara worked a good amount on Hanasaku Iroha, and I feel a very similar vibe from this opening, so there’s some real potential here.  Plus I’m enough Japanese to feel spiritually connected to fish and the ocean, so I’m really this show’s to lose here.  Come on Aquatope, you can do it!

Potential: 75%

Tsuki ga Michibiku Isekai Douchuu

Short Synopsis: Highschooler gets reincarnated into another world in Isekai’s latest shallow attempt at humorous meta-commentary on the genre.

Lenlo: Let’s be honest: This is just a crappy Konosuba/Cautious Hero/”Insert Isekai Deconstruction here”. Like these other shows Tsuki wants us to believe it’s different. That it’s aware of the tropes, that we are all in on the joke and that by acknowledging that fact we can all laugh at the meta-humor that is Tsuki’s main shtick. But like the rest of these Isekai Tsuki fails to realize that acknowledging the tropes and the jokes is not the same as deconstructing them. There are still levels, the MC is still powerful, there’s still a harem/waifu’s, etc etc. Tsuki falls into all the same traps on purpose but fails to do anything remotely interesting with them. Instead it approaches all of them with an on the nose and obvious sense of humor. And if you ask me? The humor sucks. There is nothing in Tsuki that you haven’t seen done better before. I don’t even like the other shows I listed here but at least they had the novelty of trying to do it first.

Potential: Watch anything else instead.

Mario: There are two contraction ideas that run through Tsuki isekai’s first episode that kind of negate each other’s power: that the show is meant to be a parody of the genre so it has the main boy character who can predict what will happen to him (mostly off the mark though), but at the same time, it sticks by the rules conveniently (as much as he proclaims otherwise, he’s still OPed as heck). The fact that despite all these it remains funny kind of speaks to its strengths. The satire humor is present there, where our man serves as a straight man that serves as good foil against his mean Goddess, the Dragon and the situation he ends up with. Should he remain helpless and have no clue how the new world works, it would bring something more interesting to the table. The ability he acquired – that he can speak other races’ languages – is interesting but yet to reach full potential. It’s a better isekai (which admittedly a low bar to begin with), and potentially a better show out of this underwhelmed season.

Potential: 30%

Meikyuu Black Company

Short Synopsis: Financial-bro gets reincarnated and has to do manual labor.  

Amun: So this is a strange trend I’ve noticed gaining some traction: anti-heroes.  Not like “shades of grey” – no, these are just terrible human beings who we have to follow around for a story.  Sometimes, it’s funny.  Last season was Sentouin, Hakenshimasu! which had a few bright spots.  No such luck with Meikyuu Black Company – this is a drab 20 minutes.  Animators’ wrists were worn for the creation of this.  Can you believe that?  They could have done another season of Heaven’s Memo Pad (never going to give that up), but nope – we get this instead.

Potential: Please make it stop.

Armitage: Okay, yeah. This is bad. This is Isekai satire done so black that its stains never wash off. Or at least I think it’s a satire? Though I might very well be giving the show too much credit because on face value, this is a story focusing on a downright hateable character. The protagonist, a self-made, high-functioning, multi-billionaire NEET feels like he’s always looking down on everyone including the audience. Instead of trying to make him stand out as much as possible the show goes so over the top with his mannerisms and monologues that it makes you want to quit watching this premiere after 5 minutes of maniacal screaming. But I am a professional who does her job judiciously, so I stuck with it to the bitter end. See, lovely reader? This is the kind of thing we put ourselves through so you don’t have to.

Potential: Advil needed.