Hatenkou Yuugi Review – 70/100


Adapting a manga. From the outside, it looks so simple: you just have to take a page and animate it accordingly. Yet practice has shown that a lot of series have trouble with this. Sometimes entire pages are omitted completely, or the writers think they’re talented and insert some boring inconsequential fillers. A great example of this is Hatenkou Yuugi. Oh, how I wanted to praise this series, but it’s an extreme example of how you can screw up manga-adaptations.

The manga had huge potential, but in the end the only thing that didn’t end up completely botched was the dialogue. It’s deep and detailed, but you can’t really praise the anime staff for it. They only literally copied the dialogue from the manga and inserted it. It’s just a matter of simple copying and pasting, and letting your voice-actors do the rest.

And really, it feels like the creators all went through a major divorce at the same time when making this series, because all other aspects are downright lazy. This series is a string of badly explained plot-twists. Heck, we never know why the third main character ends up travelling with the other two characters in the first place, characters like to god-mode themselves out of any problems and any substance outside of the dialogue has been completely removed.

To top that, the creators apparently found out very late that they only had 10 episodes to work with. The result is a very amusing but downright disastrous final episode that thunders through revelations at a speed of Mach 5 in order to be able to finish on time, and it still remains an ending that leaves a bad taste in your mouth. I hope that future directors will use this series as an example of how not to adapt a manga, because it’s such a shame that another story with potential had to be ruined. This series remained enjoyable because of its short length and dialogue, but it could have become so much more.

Some quick first impressions: Wagaya no Oinarisama, Neo Angelique Abyss and Da Capo II Second Season

Wagaya no Oinarisama

The best thing about this series? The soundtrack. It surprises me as well, but Wagaya no Oinarisama has been the first series this season where the background music has stood out for me. All other series up till now featured either some cheesy J-Pop (not really my taste to say the least) or obligatory dark tunes that do their job. In this series, however, the music is subtle, yet very varied. One moment you hear a violin, then comes a flute, and then it’s the turn for the piano. Also, any soundtrack that has a choir is automatically win in my opinion. About the rest of the series: it’s solid so far. The characters are likable, and there’s some good chemistry between them. The story is nothing special, but this series seems to go for the slice-of-life route anyway. For now, it’s looking interesting enough.

Neo Angelique Abyss

Okay, let me correct that statement a bit: nearly every soundtrack that has a choir is automatically win in my opinion. You can of course always take it too far. I’ve found that obscure series are always either incredibly good or incredibly bad, and this one’s obviously of the bad kind. Really, it’s hilarious to see all the clichés present: a huge cast of bishies, all great fighters, a pretty female lead who has huge powers that enable her to stand in the centre of all these bishies, lots of angelic themes, and as a bonus, the evil power of the bad guy’s monsters turns out to give everyone it touches (except for the bishies for some strange reason) wrinkles. Of course, the worst fear for any young girl! I’ve ranted a lot about bad shounen-series, but that doesn’t mean that the shoujo-series don’t have their disasters as well. 😛

Da Capo II Second Season

Err… don’t ask me why I found it a good idea to check out the fourth instalment of Da Capo. It was worth a good laugh at the predictable plot here (and of course the waking-up scene couldn’t be missing), but I admit that there have been far worse series this season than this one. This is really another one of those “rainy-day anime”, which you can watch on a rainy day if you need to spend time other than taking for example your dog out to walk. However, that takes me to the huge size of this franchise. Including this series, there’ll be 78 freaking episodes. I acknowledge that this is a nice series to relax and all, but I really can’t imagine myself sitting through 10 episodes of virtually the same over and over again, let alone eighty-seven.

Some quick first impressions: Zettai Karen Children, Code Geass – Lelouch of the Revellion R2 and Nabari no Ou

Zettai Karen Children

Well, here’s a surprise. I was about to condemn this series to the depths of hell, but it actually turned out quite entertaining for a light watch. It’s definitely not meant to be taken seriously, but series like that are nice once in a while as well. It really reminded me of a raunchy version of Power Puff Girls Z, and that definitely has potential for the future. There’s just one thing: I still don’t understand what people find so good about Hirano Aya. Her voice is annoying and way too exaggerated, and probably the most annoying thing of this first episode. What this series needs to do now is introduce interesting side-characters, and keep itself fresh throughout its entire run. I also hope that the big bad guy isn’t entirely serious and has a humorous side as well. A lot of good comedies have been ruined before because the major villain took himself too seriously.

Code Geass – Lelouch of the Revellion R2

No, that’s not a typo. Apparently, it’s the official spelling of this series according to this episode. In any case, this episode had a few too many things in common with a bad soap. Amnesia? Suzaku who has become even more stereotypical than he already was? The military knew about Lelouch, and yet they didn’t kill him as soon as they got the chance? This series is becoming harder and harder to take seriously. Ah well, at least it’ll be good for some brainless action, and with a bit of luck the upcoming episodes will become so over-the-top that they’ll be worth a good laugh.

Nabari no Ou

That main character sounds way too much like a girl! Whenever he talks, I keep seeing a strange Shana/Nagi/Louise clone acting tsundere. In any case, Nabari no Ou has solid production-values, but I’m not that excited about this series. Perhaps its the fairly generic premise so far, perhaps it’s the fact that the main cast all consists out of bishies while all the bad guys are ugly, or perhaps it’s because none of the characters has been particularly interesting so far. It’s not like I expected anything from this series, but it’s still a shame that it turned out so generic so far.

Porfy no Nagai Tabi – 14


Amazing, simply amazing. At first sight, this series looks so simple, and yet this episode was so incredibly sad. That’s really the difference between a World Masterpiece Theatre series and a regular anime. They just go into so much more detail than your usual anime. In addition to that, everything feels so natural. Porfy, Mina and Zaimis just feel like real children, and that’s exactly why this series has turned into my favourite series of the winter-season.

The episode starts in the refugee camp, where Zaimis’ mother is showing Zaimis, Porfy, Helena and Mina her newborn baby. Porfy finds it cute, and Helena compares it to an angel. Zaimis says how she looks like him, though Porfy doubts it. Zaimis’ mother says how her eyes resemble her father’s, after which Zaimis starts crying. Porfy tries to cheer up Zaimis by reminding him that he’s become a brother. Helena asks what kind of name they’ve come up for her, and Porfy answers that it would have been Erupii (god knows how you spell that). Helena fins it a very good name, and her father will definitely look over her from heaven. Zaimis’ mother says that she’s going to have to try her best for Erupii’s sake as well. Porfy then gives Zaimis the angel he carved.

Zaimis recognizes it, and is delighted that Porfy managed to fix it, and he sows it to his new sister, saying how it’s the first present her brother made for her. Next up, it’s time for lunch, though Mina refuses to eat. Porfy asks whether she’s had enough, and tells her that she really needs to eat, after which she takes a small piece of her bread. Near them is Damon, who’s having trouble eating his own soup because of his hand, so Porfy stands up and feeds him. Damon thanks him, and Porfy apologizes about the things he said to him about God and all. Damon finds it no problem, and it’s perfectly understandable for someone who just lost his parents to say such things out of rage.

Porfy says that Damon has also lost his family during the war (WWII, probably). Damon answers that a lot of his parents and siblings died back then. Porfy asks how he should get over this, and what should he do? Damon answers that even though you can’t meet them, his friends are still in his heart. He often speaks to them, like how he tells his mother how beautiful the ocean is, and how delicious the soup is. Porfy, however, says that they’re not going to answer, so what’s the point? Damon says that this isn’t necessarily the case, and he says that Porfy will never be alone, and that he can always meet his parents. He then stands up, saying that he’ll be leaving now, and how there’s a bus waiting for him. He’ll be going to Athens.

Porfy asks whether he’ll be all right during the journey, after which Damon draws a map of the main land of Greece, placing two circles: one for Simitra and the other one for Athens.
It’ll be a long journey, but he’s glad to have met Porfy, and he tells him to take good care of his sister. Next up, Louise also leaves. She’s got a sister in a nearby village with whom she can live. She notes how it must be tough for Porfy, and wishes both him and Mina good luck. Then, an expensive-looking car arrives, and a man and a woman step out. Helena then comes walking out of the church, along with a young girl who seems to have lost her entire family.

Porfy asks whether those people are the girl’s parents, though Zaimis says he’s wrong. The children who lost all their parents are going to be adopted into new families. Zaimis also heard the girl the day before, and it seems she did have a sibling, though he (or she?) found it too troublesome to take care of her. Porfy then gets very angry, and Zaimis apologizes. He says that Porfy and Mina will definitely be fine. He then leaves, to go back to his sister. Helena then talks to Porfy, who asks whether the girl had lost her parents, and Helena says that she did. He desperately asks her what’ll happen to the two of them. Helena says that she has of course been thinking about the two of Porfy and Mina, and Porfy says that he’ll refuse to separate from Mina. Helena says she understands.

Porfy then brings Mina to the sea. We then switch to Helena as she’s in her “office”, as Barnes arrives. He asks where Porfy and Mina are, and Helena says that they went to the sea. He asks how the two of them are doing, Helena says that Mina has been heavily emotionally hurt, and Porfy too has had to endure an enormous shock. Ever since he heard that his parents died, he hasn’t cried even once. We then switch to a bit later, when Barnes meets Porfy. He asks whetehr he’s been doing fine, and gives him another chocolate bar. Porfy then shares it with Mina. Porfy then says to Barnes that he’s been thinking, and he things that he’s going to start working for real, and asks whether he knows a good place.

Barnes says that Porfy is twelve years old, and has to have something more important to do than just that. Porfy then says that he’s about to get separated from Mina, though Barnes assures him that they’ll be fine. Porfy should now be thinking of nothing but Mina. She’s suffered a heavy loss, and needs a lot of attention to recover. Porfy says that Mina hasn’t become sick, and Barnes acknowledges this, though she needs to sort out a lot in her head.

The summary of the next half is going to be a bit shorter. Still detailed, but I feel like I’ve been getting too carried away with this entry. ^^; Porfy’s next plan is to go back to Simitra, to say a final goodbye to their house. And of course, to check up on whether Apollo has survived the earthquake. Zaimis is very worried about Porfy’s trip (who wouldn’t, after suddenly losing so many dear ones?) On the way, Porfy restores one of the poles with a picture of a priest on it. Porfy tells Mina how these were used when a person died, so that the deceased can visit another country.

When they arrive on Patagos Grand Station, Porfy tries to keep himself strong in front of Mina, and looks among the rubble for his father’s toolkit, and puts the contents in a bag. Meanwhile, Mina walks over to what once was the house, and sees how her tree finally blossomed. She then finally speaks again (she hasn’t talked AT ALL since she found out about her parents). Porfy then builds the same pole-house as shown before, and puts the picture of Christ that he received from Damon inside it, so that Christopher and Aneke can have a safe journey through the world. Mina then puts a branch of her tree on it.

Then, a squeak sounds, and Apollo turns out to be fine. Mina then finally laughs again, after which Porfy and Mina leave again. Tony then passes them, and finds out about the fate of Porfy’s parents. He offers to let them stay at his own house, though Porfy declines, as he wants to go back to Zaimis. Tony then offers the two of them a trip to the refugee station.

When they get back, Helena scolds Porfy about how he shouldn’t just run off as Zaimis takes Tony along to show him his new sister. Porfy then introduces Helena to Apollo. We then switch to dinner, as Porfy tells Zaimis’ mother how he went back to get his father’s tools. She then asks how things were in the village, and Porfy says that things were very quiet, and wonders where everyone went. Zaimis is really worried about whether they can return to Simitra, though his mother believes that they can.

Porfy plans to start Patagos Grand Station one day. He doesn’t know when, but he’ll come back one day to fulfil his father’s dream. He then mentions the tale of Orpheus, and both he and Zaimis agree that they wouldn’t look behind. If there was a chance that would bring their parents back, they’d never look back. Mina then falls asleep, Porfy promises to watch over her and the episode ends.

My favourite character of this episode was without a doubt Mina. Never have I seen a girl who just found out that her parents suddenly died as well portrayed as in her case. Notice how she never, ever goes against Porfy, and goes with him, even though she doesn’t feel to. She does exactly what he tells her to do. Remember back when Porfy had his “genius plan” of putting nails on the road, and Mina tried to stop him, though Porfy retorted that it was because she kept romanticizing over the movie that she just saw? Without a doubt, this must have made a bigger impression on her than Porfy could have imagined. When the two of them argued again after she just woke up after the earthquake, and how she yelled at Porfy only to find out that Christopher and Aneke were dead, of course she’d be way too scared to ever go against her brother, because only bad things come from it.

Another thing that’s portrayed in this series, better than any I’ve ever seen is the refugee camp. Because Porfy and Mina spend so much time on it, and they’re not the only ones who have lost someone dear to them, it’s strangely enjoyable to watch how all the adults try to take care of the children a bit, and try to comfort them about their losses. Especially Helena and Zaimis’ mother have really helped in distracting Porfy from all the things that happened, and I’m especially liking Zaimis’ mother more and more.

Some quick first impressions: Kanokon, Blassreiter and Kamen no Maid Guy

Kanokon

Xebec has really fallen. Once they were a studio that brought quality-series like The Third and Hitohira, though this season their only focus seems to be fanservice. Really, I don’t know what’s left to say about these series in which the male main character suddenly gets loved by a bunch of beautiful girls for no reason. They’re bad, and just depend on their fanservice to make as many otaku buy their DVDs as possible. At least, I have to give this series credit that the dialogue seems a bit more inspired than usual series of this kind, but that’s to be expected with this being based on a light novel.

Blassreiter

To be honest, this episode didn’t give me any reason to condemn this series as an utter failure. There were a few problems here and there, where the animation looked rather unnatural, but overall this turned into a very capable action-series. And therein lies the problem, though. It’s been a really long time since I watched a “good” action series, and something really has to be wrong when the most satisfying action scenes I’ve seen for the past year came from Power Puff Girls Z. Action-series like Devil May Cry, who had great first episodes also turned out to consist of nothing but fillers, and while Gurren Lagann was entertaining, it still wasn’t really what I was looking for. Blassreiter definitely has the potential, but I first want to see whether it won’t screw up its future episodes before I get my hopes up too high.

Kamen no Maid Guy

Well, it’s a good thing that this seems to be a season of shoujo anyway, so I didn’t have any big expectations for this series. I maybe chuckled trice during this episode, which is way too little for a good comedy. This series really seems to try too hard, but all it does is waste a lot of energy on fanservice jokes that get boring really fast. I don’t even mind the bad animation, but there’s so much you can do with a concept of a GAR maid with a mask, and this series seems to choose the most predictable route through lots and lots of fanservice. I’m going to give this series one more chance, to see whether it’s perhaps like Muteki Kanbanmusume, though for now I won’t recommend this one.

Arusu the Adventure Review – 86/100


As a continuation to Mahou Shoujotai, Studio 4C brought out a six-part OVA called Arusu the Adventure. There are a few things you should know before watching it: it’s in no way as epic as the original series. Everything about Arusu the Adventure is light-hearted, and if you were put off by the childish moments of the original series, then you certainly won’t like the OVA. Arusu the Adventure has no main storyline, and instead is a string of standalone episodes, all dedicated to either flesh out certain points of Mahou Shoujotai, or showcase some more cultural habits in the world of the witches. Ever wondered where the dragon house came from? Or the background of Grand Master? Well, this OVA provides the answers.

The best parts of this OVA, however, are the stunning visuals. Mahou Shoujotai already looked absolutely gorgeous, but Arusu the Adventure looks even better, and it made perfect use of the experimental nature of the series. Throughout the six episodes, the creators keep changing from one art style to the other, and each and every episode, no matter how strange they may look, turns into a visual feast. The soundtrack also got updated with a few new tracks, and they too fit this series perfectly.

Standalone, Arusu the Adventure isn’t anything special, but it does contribute to my most favourite series ever and for that I’m more than willing to call it a success. The storytelling may be very sloppy at times, but this is a perfect OVA to watch if you want to relax, as opposed to the chaotic nature of Mahou Shoujotai, and it still shines in terms of graphics, music and creativity. I’m really looking forward to find out Studio 4C’s next work. Pleeaase let it be another tv-series!!!

Arusu the Adventure – 06


Ah, and so it’s finally ended. With this, after 52 episodes of 10 minutes, or 26 episodes of 20 minutes, whichever way you look at it, Mahou Shoujotai is now really over. This episode was like the others: light-hearted, yet strangely compelling. And finally Alice plays the part of main character again. And is it me, or did this episode feature some brand-new tracks of soundtrack?

I’m going to keep this entry short, because everything I wanted to say about this series has already been said in my entries of the previous five episodes, and I still need to write a spoiler-free review about this one. I do want to say, however, that the graphics for this episode yet again looked awesome.

Some quick first impressions: Druaga no Tou ~The Aegis of Uruk~, Amatsuki and Itazura na Kiss

Druaga no Tou ~The Aegis of Uruk

Well, this episode turned out to be something entirely different than expected. You can say a lot about Gonzo, but I don’t think that anyone can say that they don’t know how to create a bad game-adaptation, and they use this perfectly to their advantage for this episode to create a hilarious RPG-parody that also takes the Mick out of popular series as Haruhi and Gurren Lagann. I was throwing all kinds of curses at Gonzo before I found out. 😛 On the other hand, however, this series still has a 16-year old male protagonist, so there’s still enough room for screwing this up. Still, it’s a good thing that Gonzo knows how not to do this series; now let’s hope that they do know how to do it properly. One hint that points in a positive direction is that none of the characters we saw in this episode, apart from the main guy and his rival, seems to be a major character. Are they going to get killed off or something? Now that would be a great opportunity for character-development.

Amatsuki

Seriously, why do so many series suddenly have first episodes of this quality!? I’ve been used to the fact that nearly every series starts out mediocre, and here series after series suddenly sparkles with potential. Really, apart from To Love-Ru and Kyou Kara Maou, I have yet to see a series this season that didn’t deliver for its first episode! In any case, Amatsuki turned out like I hoped it would: a wolf in sheep’s clothing. On one side, it’s reminiscent of a Kyou Kara Maou-clone without any sexual innuendo, and then suddenly the main character sees a huge beast slaughtered in front of him. Don’t make the mistake that this will be an ultra cheerful series, because this series isn’t afraid to deal with the darker topics.

Itazura na Kiss

The past Autumn- and Winter-season featured an unexpected wave of good shounen-romance series, though this really seems to be the turn for the shoujo-romances to shine again. It’s felt like ages since a good one popped up, after the disappointing Shugo Chara and all. For Itazura na Kiss, the character-designs look very simple, but that’s the beauty of it: neither the males nor the females feel exceptionally beautiful, like you see in so many other series. Heck, our main female lead is befriended with a couple of punks. The story for this series isn’t anything special, and it’s just meant to get another boy and girl in one house, but what really shines in this series is its lovable cast of characters. It’s just been one episode, and already the characters feel diverse and have shown the viewer multiple sides. Now all that’s left is to hope that this series won’t delve into useless fillers, but I’m pretty confident with the director and the music composer of Toward the Terra and the animation-company of Kaze no Shoujo Emily.

Ghost Hound Review – 92/100


If you’re looking for a standard anime with a standard storyline, then you should stay well away from Ghost Hound. This is one series that tries to be different, and it’s at the same time after Shion no Ou my favourite series to have aired during the past Autumn Season. It does feature a bunch of fourteen/fifteen year old boys, but this series manages to use them to their full extend.

One of the major themes of Ghost Hound is psychology. You can see that the creators are very knowledgeable about the subject, because this series really delves into the details of this subject. All main characters have run into their own kinds of traumas due to various things that happened in their childhood, and everyone has reacted to this differently. Ghost Hound shows how these people can be cured, and how just a small push in the wrong direction can lead to disaster.

There’s another thing that really sets this series apart from most others: it’s been directed by the director of Serial Experiments Lain, and it shows. Apart from that series, there is no other anime I can think of that puts more focus on its sound effects than Ghost Hound. The result is an continuously tight atmosphere as the events slowly develop.

And yes, this is a slow series, but don’t make the mistake that nothing happens. In fact, every episode builds up for the next one, and it keeps you on your toes, because you’ll never know when a sudden plot-twist might arrive. In this series, it’s not the destination that matters, but the road at which you get there. Because of this, the ending ended up being a tad rushed, but thankfully entertaining enough to keep interesting.

I didn’t have much series to look forward to at the previous Autumn Season, but this one really stood out, and it’s along with Shion no Ou my top-recommendation amongst the shows that aired back then. Don’t worry that it’ll start off slow, it’ll pick up its pace quickly enough and deliver a great storyline, an interesting cast of characters that develops very natural-like and a feast for the senses.

Ghost Hound – 22


It’s strange. This episode was far from perfect. Like expected after the previous episode, a lot of things indeed had to be crammed in one episode. We still don’t know where Masayuki’s mother went (either that, or it was mentioned somewhere in a previous episode and I didn’t pick it up), and just happily reappeared again at the end of this episode. Makoto’s mother also didn’t show up at all, and this episode yet introduced all kinds of new concepts. Compared to the extremely solid series, this episode wasn’t careful in its building up at all. So why did I like this episode so much?

I think that there are a couple of different endings a series can choose. Endings often used in comedies and light-hearted series are the “life goes on”-ending, the “there is no ending”. There’s also the “aftermath ending”, where nothing exciting happens and instead the series closes off with a quiet episode. Then there are the series who want to end with a bang, and they can usually be divided into three categories.

In the least exciting of the three, the final episode just takes the end of the semi-final episode and wraps up all the threads that were still left hanging from it. Most of the series from the past fall and winter-season belong in this category, and while it’s nice and all, I don’t really see such an ending as anything special. Shion no Ou is one of the few series who actually made such an ending really work, but that series was awesome to begin with.

In the second category, the creators basically solve all of the problems in the semi-final episode, apart from one major thing. Think of it as, the evil emperor’s plans have all been destroyed, and now all that’s left is to defeat the evil emperor himself. These endings are usually very solid ones, take Clannad’s ending, or one of my favourites: Bokura no. These endings, however, also have a tendency to get quite boring if you’re not into the series.

And then the third, which is my personal favourite but also an incredibly double-edged sword: introduce new things in the final episode. And this is exactly where Ghost Hound’s ending belongs. There were only four series for the past season who did this, I think: Mokke, Ghost Hound, Hakaba Kitarou and Wellber no Monogatari. While Wellber’s ending was a string of bad ideas, the other three contained some of my favourite endings of the past season, simply because you really won’t know what to expect. A lot of my favourite endings are also of this type (Ooedo Rocket, The Third, Night Head Genesis, Noein), and now I finally see the resemblances.

But yeah, endings like these can also go horribly wrong, simply because there’s so much that happens in just one episode. Ghost Hound barely avoided this, and thankfully it more than made up for this by resolving more than I thought it would. Hirata gets a very nice closure, and in the end, it didn’t leave a bad taste behind.

Strangely enough, my favourite character in this episode ended up Michio. He was really fun to watch as he tried to use the ghosts of the deceased bioids to get rid of the strange typhoon. The old guy in the woods got a very interesting role as observer, along with a bunch of psychics who were alarmed by Noriko’s actions. And of course Tarou looked awesome in his priestess-outfit.

And really, what was up with that sudden landslide that destroyed the Oogami house? I guess that the spirits must have been pretty angry at Noriko. ^_^;;

The thing about this episode was also that it lets the viewer figure out what happened, and gets away with it pretty well. Either that or I didn’t pay attention during the previous episode in which everything about that typhoon got explained. Makoto suddenly summoned his ghost hound in front of a bunch of goons, at first sight this may have come from nowhere, but I guess that with the typhoon, certain spirits that would have been invisible otherwise appeared for everyone to see.

The same goes for that green-haired guy. I’m still surprised that he featured such little screen time. He was just there, never said anything, stole the completed bioid and threw it in the lake. After that, he’s gone! With no traces left behind. Did that guy work for Noriko as well, or did he have his own plans in the end?

And in the end, Tarou has managed to figure out what happened to his sister’s spirit. Miyako wasn’t the reincarnation of her at all, it indeed seems that the two just looked alike. Instead, she has been inside Tarou all this time. This episode also ended on an interesting note, with a picture being taken, just like what happened with Makoto’s parents.