Some Quick First Impressions: Magia Record, Eizouken ni wa Te wo Dasu na, and ID: Invaded

Magia Record: Madoka Magica Gaiden

Short Synopsis: Two magical girls travel to a city that appears in their dreams, promising that they can be saved.

Wooper’s review:

I’m a fan of the original Madoka series, but without Shinbo, Urobuchi, or Kajiura aboard the creative team here, I was ready for disappointment. Thankfully, though, this was a pretty good episode! It certainly doesn’t ease you into things the way 2011 Madoka did – the plot is more upfront with its intentions thanks to the whole “In Kamihama City, magical girls can be saved” tag line. That’s not a dealbreaker for me, as Magia Record’s beautiful backdrops and eerie atmosphere combine to offset its accelerated start. That things are not quite right is obvious, since all traces of magical girl Iroha’s sister have been wiped from existence, and there’s a second Kyubey at work that only she can sense. The show does more than obsess over those facts, however – it plasters the facades of buildings with the wishes of magical girls, and bathes key scenes in a haunting twilight gold to great effect. Gekidan Inu Curry (the art duo who created the labyrinths from the original series) definitely brought their A-game as full series directors here. They’re also listed as the project’s head writers, so their compositional chops will be tested in the coming months. After this premiere, though, I’m throwing caution to the wind and approaching Magia Record with full-blown optimism.

Potential: 80%

Lenlo’s review:

Similarly to Wooper, I am also a fan of the original Madoka Magica series, and was worried about Urobuchi and co’s absence. And while my fears have not completely disappeared, I did enjoy the opening episode of Magia Record. I think the directors did a great job of keeping the atmosphere and general feel of the original series. The mixed-media segments as well were splendidly done, really brought me back and are still like nothing else you really see in anime. Really, Wooper pretty much hit the nail on the head above. Personally, my only concern is whether or not Magia Record can manage to not become what Madoka Magica originally satirized. Whether or not it can manage to avoid becoming a basic monster of the week story of magical girl show, with a slightly darker tint. So long as it avoids that pitfall, I have no reason to think this won’t be a good series.

Potential: 80%

 

Eizouken ni wa Te wo Dasu na!

Short Synopsis: Three high school girls living in a densely organized seaside town decide to make an anime together.

Wooper’s review:

I think it’s safe to say that Eizouken’s release marks the most spartan phase of Yuasa’s anime career. Here there is no trace of Mind Game’s messiness, Tatami Galaxy’s multimedia experimentation, or Devilman Crybaby’s elastic psychosis. There are chase scenes and wonderfully lived-in backgrounds – both staples of his previous work – but the simplicity of the character designs isn’t pushed to its limits. That doesn’t mean they’re boring; on the contrary, their Dragon Pilot-inspired features and varying heights make Eizouken’s unlikely leading trio fun to root for. The stakes are very low, however, as the story hasn’t presented us with much more than their desire to make anime. There’s a direct Future Boy Conan reference, a handful of big animator namedrops, and some very nerdy dialogue about how anime uses plausible movement as a basis for impossible movement – but not much in the way of story. We’ll get there in time, I suppose, and until then we can busy ourselves by studying the Where’s Waldo-esque backgrounds and loosely colored fantasy sequences where the characters’ concept designs come to life. I’ll be watching this one going forward, but I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t disappointed by its ordinary nature.

Potential: 70%

Mario’s review:

Anyone who loves and is inspired by Future Boy Conan gets a thumb of approval from me.

Watching this first episode I can totally see why Yuusa would want to adapt it. The looseness of the characters’ designs fits his fluid animation well, and when it comes to the anime-filled imagination he can stretch the muscle to go wild. What I found the most noticeable is his restraint. Not experimental in any nature, no wild visuals or colorful palette; he instead tones down to fit the material, and for me this is a big plus. The show so far has two main parts: the real world where three girls with different personalities and skills join up to make their own anime (I found the whole rich girl runaway from her bodyguards a bit over the top but… well), and their anime “production” that makes full use of the main girl’s concept art – something I really want to see more of. Not a totally knockout premiere, but it has many bright parts that I am happy to follow it along the way.

Potential: 75%

 

ID: Invaded

Short Synopsis: A self-proclaimed Master Detective goes into the subconscious of a serial killer in order to solve the case.

Mario’s review:

ID:Invaded is a hot mess. Well, parts of it are by design, but when you have an episode (I only watched the first one) of a dreamstate of floating objects, a real life crime procedural and all the too-important-and-not-funny-at-all talks between a dozen characters, it’s a bit too much. The very concept is intriguing – a mixture of 18if and Psycho-Pass – that can push the story into interesting territories. While it does what it could to visualize the fragmented dream world, there are some drawbacks to that. First, on the technical level the CG can be bland and noticeable at times. The CG of the loose body parts are fine, but the character models suffer badly. Second, for the amount of time that we are inside the killer’s mind, we sadly don’t know much about him, or any character at all. The narrative functions as establishing the rules and its worldbuilding more than it cares enough to build any believable or relatable character. Still, it’s interesting enough for me to give this show another try.

Potential: 40%

Amun’s review:

I came into this show (a double feature at that) with the lowest expectations. I hated the character designs in the preview and we just came off some terribly disappointing detective shows in Sherlock and Psycho Pass (not Season 1). But ID: Invaded caught me by surprise: this wasn’t the cleanest pair of episodes by any means, but I’m hooked for at least a few more. The CG doesn’t annoy me as much as I thought, and the character designs are dulled after a while like olfactory fatigue. What shines here is the general world concept (more Minority Report than Psycho Pass in my opinion), and I surprisingly liked the characters, despite their looks and the overall brief interactions. Even the villain had more depth than expected for a guy who drilled a hole in his own head – maybe it’s just a talented VA? Anyways, I’m around for a few more – just don’t hoodwink me like Sherlock did.

Potential: 65%