Full Metal Alchemist – Brotherhood – 03



Short Synopsis: The Lior-Episode.
Episode Rating: 6,5/10 (Lacking, but that was to be expected)
So yeah, with this you can consider Natsu no Arashi dropped and FMA picked up. Just don’t think that I’m going to sing continuous praises for this one though; be sure to expect me to whine about this series a lot during the beginning episodes. It took me three attempts before I managed to get through those very dull first thirteen episodes of the original series. Because of that, this episode was the fourth time I had to sit through the Lior-story, so yeah: it did get on my nerves.

Thankfully, Brotherhood handled it better than the original series did: it condensed everything effectively to only one episode and it still managed to show the most important things of this arc. What I’m hoping for with this series is the Glass Mask effect: the original Glass Mask series of 1984 was utterly terrible, but the 2005-remake, which adapted the exact same manga chapters and took nearly the exact same amount of time somehow made the exact same story awesome. While this episode wasn’t exactly good, I do have to admit that the first few episodes are a major improvement on their counterparts in the original series.

My only fear is that the creators may be trying to rush through the first chapters a bit too quickly. Rose and the priest for example, were just as dull as I remembered them, but what I really liked in this episode is how the chemistry between the characters is much more enjoyable: especially Ed and Al are now much more interesting to watch, and I wonder whether the creators can keep this up. One of the major flaws of the original series was that the creators wanted to show off Ed’s l33t-powers a bit too badly. While the radio in this episode was cute, in the subsequent arcs, whenever Ed and Al arrived in a new town, there was always some sort of Timmy that fell in some sort of well that happened to be near Ed so that he could show everyone how awesome his powers are by saving him. I’m interested to see how Brotherhood is going to avoid this.

Also, there’s one part I didn’t get about this episode, so perhaps the manga readers can fill this in for me: how exactly did the priest know exactly that Ed and Al performed human transmutation? I mean, there are other ways in which people can lose limbs, aren’t there? If Ed didn’t happen to live near a very good artificial limb creator (or whatever they’re called), he’d still be limp at this point, and I’m not sure why a body-less armor immediately means a failed human transmutation either. I mean, in the original series, none of the other people who transmuted brought whatever soul they sacrificed back into an armor, did they?

So yeah; I like Full Metal Alchemist, but just not the beginning. I believe that the turning point for me was the arrival of Armstrong, so until that point you can pretty much expect me to be rather negative on this series. Brotherhood really improved the chemistry between the characters, but the plot right now still is preachy and uninteresting.

Cross Game – 03



Short Synopsis: Kou gets invited to substitute in a local baseball team.
Episode Rating: 8/10 (Excellent)
Oh this show is SO good. It may be one of the dark horses of the season, but in three episodes it has already done what most series can’t even do in twice that amount. Don’t get fooled off by the simplistic character-designs, because as a series focusing on middle- and high-school kids it does so many things right. This episode again had such a wonderful combination between subtle humour and drama, slice of life, character-development. There are already so many different characters, and yet all of them feel different with their own personalities.

And even though the character-designs are simplistic and leave out a lot of details, they still feel realistic: the school is filled with all different kinds and shapes of people of which a surprising amount is obese (really: finally after Real Drive we finally have another show that realizes that not everyone has the perfect body). What I also like is the people like the captain of Aoba’s baseball team: usually in anime these guys are the evil punks, who do evil stuff because they’re evil, or they’re especially that exaggerated to make fun of these stereotypes, but this guy feels nothing like that: he’s just a regular middle schooler with a tough physique.

As for the main character, it was of course obvious that he was going to be very talented at baseball, but the writers gave him quite an interesting back-story for it. Like Touch, he never went to join the baseball club in middle school, but unlike Touch this was because of a fight that broke out when he attempted to join it three years before. Instead, he just kept practicing by himself because his parents were involved with baseball anyway. It makes sense: the past three episodes have really shown that he’s a carefree guy who doesn’t like to get into trouble, and yet at the same time you can see how he’s still affected by something that happened three years ago. I don’t recall having seen anyone cry about Wakaba’s death, but you can see its influence very subtly in all of the characters that she hung out with when she was still alive.

Valkyria Chronicles – 03



Short Synopsis: Wellkin’s first mission as the commander of Squad 7.
Episode Rating: 7,5/10 (Good)
Now this is more like it. Now that we’ve arrived at the real meat of the story, I’ve gotten a lot more interested in this series. The idiot siblings thankfully don’t play a major part in this show at all and Welkin’s strategies are actually quite interesting and creative. I’m also glad that Alicia got herself an interesting position as vice-chief of Squad 7: it’s going to allow her to grow as a character, and also prevent her from screwing up completely because Welkin will be there.

This episode also introduced some of the major side-characters of this series, most notably Largo Potter and Brigitte Stark. I liked how the two of them brought a bit of conflict into this episode, in which they weren’t that convinced by a commander who came fresh out of university. I also wonder where all of the hatred for the ‘darksen’ comes from. Is it mere nationalism (understandable in times of war, of course), or were the darksen people once notorious for something they did.

Still, this series is going to have to continue to bring in these interesting situations, because at this point it’s just oh so tempting to fill the rest of the show with random battles every episode until the final boss has to be faced in episode 25. Especially the character-development for the side-characters has the potential to just stop completely after this episode.

Eden of the East – 02



Short Synopsis: Saki and ‘Akira’ arrive in Tokyo.
Episode Rating: 8/10 (Excellent)
Okay, thanks for some of the comments. I think with this I established my blogging schedule for this season (do note that the days are in my timezone, not necessarily at the day they air):
Monday: Shangri-La, Konnichiwa Anne
Tuesday: 07-Ghost
Wednesday: Nada
Thursday: Ristorante Paradiso
Friday: Pandora Hearts, Basquash, Phantom, Eden of the East
Saturday: Nope
Sunday: Valkyria Chronicles, Cross Game, Guin Saga, Full Metal Alchemist – Brotherhood

Based on various comments I received, I realized that there are a lot of people who’d like to see me blog both Valkyria Chronicles and FMA, so I’m probably going to drop Natsu no Arashi instead. While that is one definite underrated series, I’m not that sure about the series right now, and whether it’ll be interesting enough to blog (at least, when compared to some other shows I’m blogging this season).

As for the rest of the shows I’m not going to blog:
– Tears to Tiara… I don’t want to go sit through another Utawarerumono.
– Souten Kouro has the bad luck that it’s about the Three Kingdoms Era. I like history, but I never really liked any of the anime that dealt with that period.
– Hatsukoi Limited, while I’m not 100% sure yet, is probably not going to live up to the standard that Sentimental Journey set for this formula it’s trying to use.

Eden of the East is also one really popular series it seems, but for me it’s just too awesome not to blog. I’m an absolute sucker for mystery, and even though it’s only been building up so far, it’s got me intrigued like no other. There seems this whole back-story behind it, and I’m dying to find out what it is.

The style of storytelling is also really addictive, with a lot of focus on the dialogue between the lead characters. What I really liked in this episode was the bit of time the creators set aside for Akira and Saki to get to know each other a bit. It’s great to have another series that’s about adults rather than the teenagers that usually overcrowd the season, and this Spring Season especially seems to have quite a few series that ignore the brats for what they are and just focus on people aged eighteen or above. And I especially like Saki in this series. She’s a young woman that has her own life and an interesting combination between a bit of an airhead and a headstrong woman who likes to take initiatives and try out different things. I also really like her voice actress.

No series is perfect of course, and the flaws with Eden so far are with the CG. It really stands out at times, especially considering how Production IG usually blends it in so well with the rest of the graphics. Here though, people randomly are cell shaded, CG cars and boats look out of place. It’s a bit of a shame considering the rest of the great animation. It’s very strange, because this series features just about the best staff of Production IG, who also worked on Seirei no Moribito.

So yeah, the budget for this series is clearly lower than it was for Seirei no Moribito, that’s the only explanation I can think of. However, the plot is just as intriguing, if not more. In this episode, we learn the meaning behind the “Noblesse Oblige” that was written on Akira’s phone. Noblesse Oblige basically means the obligation of rich people to take care of the poor. The organization Akira belonged to is called the Celecau, who I guess originally was formed by someone with a lot of money in order to help those in need. Somewhere along the way though, something went wrong and the members started up terrorism. I’m interested to find out why the heck the one who organized everything let everything go out of control this way.

In any case, my entries for this series are probably going to be later than usual, since I’m rather busy on Fridays (both with my studies and other shows that need to be blogged) and the raws usually air too late on Thursday for me. It’s interesting how the subs are already fast enough to be released in that kind of period, though, although I kind of get why speedsubbers are often criticized when watching this episode. Especially the translation notes of Ground Zero were pretty pointless.

Pandora Hearts – 03



Short Synopsis: Oz ends up at the abyss, otherwise known as a VERY WEIRD PLACE.
Episode Rating: 8/10 (Excellent)
Right now, I find it really hard to establish a Top 3 of the season so far: there is no show that stands far above the others yet, but at the same time this season does have a selection of excellent shows, so I’ll just stick with a top 5 shows for now, in random order: Phantom, Eden, Cross Game, Guin Saga and of course Pandora Hearts. The first three episodes so far have been nothing short of excellence.

The whole mindfuck of this series continues even in this episode, in which Oz ends up in the abyss that is filled with disturbing living toys, half-broken houses, doors and things that you usually find inside a doll house, but this time surrounded into a strange black goo and surrounded by strange black clouds. I believe that this is one of the first times I’ve seen horror combined with fantasy in anime, and it works really well, considering all of the weird stuff that this episode threw to the viewer.

And at the same time it doesn’t forget to flesh out the characters. I personally really like the combination of Oz and Alice, and how it’s impossible to know at this point what exactly Alice’s goals are: all that we know is that she needs someone like Oz in order to be able to escape the Abyss (which to be honest is really not an enjoyable place to live), but why she ended up there in the first place, or what she was before she arrived there are still huge mysteries. And at the same time she also could simply have ended up there like Oz: an innocent victim. Although I doubt that she’s going to remain innocent, with the ability to transform into a huge black rabbit and all.

Phantom – 03



Short Synopsis: Zwei has been trained enough and is about to face his final test.
Episode Rating: 8/10 (Excellent)
Why do all the good shows air on the same days?!

In any case, this was a very strong episode for Phantom, and it’s still one of my favourites for this season. While at first sight a standard bee-train series, with very obvious similarities to Noir, there are definitely parts in which it is different. The biggest one is how much attention it spends to the realism of gun combat, and that’s something I can really appreciate. In this show, it’s in no way a matter of just point-shoot-kill, but it’s much more a matter of using your brains, and it also becomes a matter of a battle of wits. In Noir, the action was much more stylized than what we’ve seen in Phantom so far.

Playing in North America, there are also of course references to El Cazador, but again Bee-Train improves on it compared to the previous work. For once, it indeed feels like we’re in a multicultural setting, rather than the Mexicans of El Cazador that may have felt a bit too Japanese. They’re small things, but still appreciated. Phantom of course misses the experimental nature of Bee-Train’s previous work, Blade of the Immortal, but this show doesn’t necessarily need anything over the top, and I really like what it so far has become.

The next question is of course going to be what the rest of the first half of this show is going to look like. With this, the introduction seems over and we’ll probably be switching to random missions and a sloooow pacing while the characters get the chance to be fleshed out (a formula that Bee-Train have really become infamous for, among others), and so I’m interested to see whether these random missions can retain the same atmosphere of these first three episodes until the real meat of the story begins. And when it does, something tells me we’ll be having an excellent cast of characters.

Basquash! – 03



Short Synopsis: Apparently, one year has passed since the first episode and some mysterious guy is wreaking havoc in Rollingtown
Episode Rating: 7,5/10 (Good)
Let me first hijack this post for a bit to react on some comments that I received on this post. I personally thought that nobody would be interested in reading my thoughts on the new FMA that already was blogged by many other people, but I might have been wrong in this. Are there more people who are interested to see me blogging that series? At this point, I can still easily swap it with Valkyria Chronicles.

In any case, regarding this episode: it was what I’d like to call creative cutting of corners. While the background art looked as solid as ever, it was clearly obvious that the animation on the foreground was rushed. More often than not, the camera would pan away from a character when he or she was talking in order to save up on trying to synchronize their lips. Interesting effect, but it remains cheap. ^^; The question is now going to be whether the budget has run out completely or the creators are just saving some budget for later episodes. It’s annoying that you can never really predict this.

Still, this episode didn’t lose the fun-factor that this series has. I especially liked how Iceman Hotty (also the guy with the weirdest name of the season) turned out to be competely different from what I expected him to be, and he seems to be suffering from either hypocrisy or a bipolar disorder: on one hand he diligently plays official basketball, and on the other hand he wreaks havoc at night because he hates street basketball.

I also liked how people actually made a monument of Dan’s mecha crashing into the baseball post a year after it happened. That’s not a statue you see every day, is it? This episode also introduced some sort of princess or daughter of a very rich person, who is probably going to play a big role in the future. Sela Miranda meanwhile is also a very strange character: she’s a talented hard-working girl who gets turned on by being dominated. I’m still not convinced at how this series made both the princess and Sera look way more composed and talented than most adults, to be honest I didn’t expect any different. What I didn’t expect was that woman with the incredibly huge bust that showed up in this episode and offered to be Dan’s manager. What the?

Touch Review – 87,5/100



Next up in the line of very long series that are very long: Touch, a baseball drama that clocks in at 101 episodes, and it was followed by three compilation movies and two more full-length TV-specials (not included for this review, though). The huge length is no reason to get scared off, though, because this movie is not only one of the finest examples of why anime of the eighties rocks, it also still stands rock-solid as one of the best high-school romances I’ve seen.

Because I must say, the creators made optimal use of the long length. The pacing for this show is very slow, but that did result into a cast of some of the most amazing characters. Especially Tatsuya and Minami receive nearly 100 episodes of pure development, that makes their characters SO believable. Each characters has his own strengths and weaknesses and grows in his or her own subtle way.

Which brings me to the second strength of Touch: absolutely nothing feels forced, and yet it’s full of unpredictable plot-twists. The creators have a knack for setting things up very naturally and yet get the best out of the characters while staying light-years away from melodrama. In fact, the big dramatic scenes are always handled with a wonderful sense of subtlety, rather than trying to squeeze as many tears out of the viewer.

But yeah, the downside of this is that this is one tough series to get through, considering the length. There are strings of tens of episodes without any sort of action and that are just focused on very slooowly fleshing out the characters. We get an outstanding view on their lives this way… but many people will find it boring, especially considering the huge length of this show. One of the challenges in storytelling is choosing a good combination between compactness and completeness, and this show might have gone on for a tad too long.

At times, I have been criticized at being a bit too harsh on anime from the seventies and eighties in my reviews, but my point is this: if those ages could produce shows that are as awesome as Touch, then why couldn’t the others have done the same? The only area at which old anime should be inferior to the newer ones is the animation quality (which by the way, for touch looks quite detailed, especially considering its length), but this series more than proves that the seventies and eighties knew more than enough about what it takes to creating an truly outstanding cast of characters.

Storytelling: 9/10
Characters: 10/10
Production-Values: 8/10
Setting: 8/10

07-Ghost – 02



Short Synopsis: Teito ends up at a strange church.
Episode Rating: 7,5/10 (Good)
I may be a bit late in noticing this, but this season features a lot of shows with excellent soundtracks, doesn’t it? We have Pandora Hearts, Phantom, Shin Mazinger, Full Metal Alchemist, Cross Game, Shangri-La, Guin Saga, 07-Ghost, Eden of the East, and I probably missed a few, all of them with some rocking background tracks.

In any case, I’ve decided to blog this show because it looks surprisingly solid despite the at first sight rather childish character-designs and voice actors (but then again, this is just typical of Studio Deen). I’m not that worried about the shounen-ai undertones getting in the way, simply becaues I HAVE SEEN SHINING TEARS X WIND. There is NO way that this show is going to be even as remotely disturbing as one particular scene from that show. Besides, so what if some of the characters are possibly gay? This episode showed that this series avoids the big pitfall of nearly every single shounen-ai series: the complete absence of straight people, and that’s enough for me. This show has shown so far that there are enough straight people.

In any case, this episode mostly was building up, and introduced the rest of the main cast apart from Teito and Ayanami, and we learn why this show is called “07-Ghost”: Teito gets saved by some priests from a nearby church who happen to run into him, and this church turns out to be a famous sacred place in which people come to get healed. It seems to have been founded by seven ghosts, hence the name 07-Ghost. Makes sense.

I’m interested to see what the creators can do with this series, and I like the mystery in it so far. There are some hints that Ayanami didn’t simply kill Teito’s father because he’s evil, and I’m curious to find out the reason behind it. At the same time, if the creators plan to go for 25 episodes, I wonder what they plan to fill the rest of the time with.

The staff behind this series isn’t the most solid, but it’ll suffice. Natsuko Takahashi is doing the series composition, and the great thing about her is that she’s got a huge amount of experience in this field. Since the source material is already looking excellent, she can use this experience in order to keep the series on track. The director meanwhile has worked on mostly uninteresting shoujo series like Hatenkou Yuugi, but he did direct Sasami Mahou Shoujo Club, so there is potential in this guy, especially if he can stick to the manga like he’s supposed to.

Konnichiwa Anne – 02



Short Synopsis: Anne wonders where her name came from.
Episode Rating: 7,5/10 (Good)
Boy, am I glad to see this one back! As for the summary: I’ll try to be accurate, but there is a lot of dialogue in this series, so there might be a few mistakes here and there.

The episode starts as Anne is hanging out the laundry to dry. Elisa returns from school early since she only had classes in the morning, and while she hoped that she’d be able to help Anne with the dishes, she arrived just too late for that. Anne believes that a kind grandmother called “wind” is going to take care of drying up the clothes (reminds me of “kaze no obaa-san” from Kaze no Shoujo emily ^^;).

Then they start talking about the cat, who Anne named “Brownie”, since it just refuses to listen to its name. While Anne wonders about giving it a better name, Eliza shows Anne a book, and she starts reading it in front of Anne (since Anne obviously loves stories like this). Anne then tries to give the cat the name of one of the characters in the story, but Elisa says that it might be better to name someone after someone in your family. Elisa’s name was given to her by her mother, and Horace and Edward got their names from their father, who apparently was so glad that boys were born into the family. This prompts Anne to wondering who it was that gave her name to her. Elisa doesn’t know, since she already was called “Ann” (apparently, it never was written down in front of her). Anne finds that name a bit too simple.

During their little talk, though, the two of them forgot time a bit, and have to rush in to get the laundry cleaned up. Inside though, the atmosphere is like that of a chicken farm: Horace and Edward are bickering as always and the little baby whose name I can’t seem to remember is crying. At that time, Elisa’s mother comes in and is angry at all of the ruckus that’s going on in front of her (not to mention all of the laundry that hasn’t been folded yet). Anne instead starts talking about how she changed the name of the cat to “Rockingba” (please don’t ask me how to spell that one…), but the mood completely crashes when the father comes in and he starts yelling at his wife because she doesn’t have dinner ready for him yet.

As it turns out, he has been drinking again, even though he’s out of a job and is relying on his wife to get money. When she stars yelling at him how there’s no money left, he smashes open a box of different ornaments and just tells her to sell those things if there isn’t any money anyway, and he walks off again. One of the other things in that box was a blanket that Anne was wrapped in when she arrived at the family. Elisa’s mother tells her how much Anne looked like her mother, and she also tells that she named Elise after her own mother for the same reason. Before Anne can ask where her own name came from, the baby starts crying again.

The next day, Anne of course fantasizes how it must have been for her mother to create said blanket, and she even gives it a name (“Mother’s Blanket”) before she’s called out to do the laundry again. Horace and Edward meanwhile are bored and decide to go out and play with the blanket. Anne catches them running off in the direction of a wild river and it starts raining. When Anne tries to stop them, they lose their balance and drop the blanket near the river-bank. When Anne tries to catch it, she slips and falls into the river. Horace tries to rescue her but he falls in too. Edward runs off to warn his parents.

When Anne and Horace finally are out of the river, they’re soaked and have no idea where they are, but thankfully they didn’t drift off for too long and are easily found. Horace starts crying and runs to his mother, while his mother got the wrong idea from Edward and thinks that it was Anne who pushed both of them into the river and so she gets really angry at Anne. When she finds out the truth later, she decides to tell Anne where her name came from: her father Walter gave it to her as well. I believe that it was named after a Queen of England that once lived, and that’s when she also learns that her name is spelled “Anne”, instead of “Ann”.

In any case, watching this series for me is going to be a matter of managing expectations, because this show has to fill some very large shoes. In the graphics department, it has to live up to the talents of Hayao Miyazaki who took care of the lay-out of the first episodes of Anne of Green Gables, and at the same time it also has the bad luck that it aired just after Porfy no Nagai Tabi, which had the most awesome background art. Konnichiwa Anne has none of them, and instead creates a style of graphics that’s much more simple, like the approach that was used in Les Miserables. In the music department, this series goes for a soundtrack that’s much more trying to blend in to the atmosphere, but it doesn’t make as much impact as the soundtrack of Porfy or Les Miserables did (although it is interesting to notice that the soundtrack is composed by those who did Jigoku Shoujo Mitsuganae, perhaps in the future it’ll get more interesting).

In terms of realism, there are other really big names that this show has to live up to: Isao Takahata and Tomomi Mochizuki: two of the best, if not the best directors when it comes to realism, and Lucy Maud Montgomery who wrote the original Anne of Green Gables novels (and also those of Kaze no Shoujo Emily). Konnichiwa Anne doesn’t have such a stellar director: Katsuyoshi Yatabe, whose work includes a hentai yaoi involving under-aged boys… yeah.

But on the other hand, looking at production staff in such a shallow way is such an inaccurate way in order to gauge the quality of a series. My favourite example is the director of The Third: the guy put down a really magnificent series… only to direct Penguin no Mondai afterwards. Or take Kaze no Shoujo Emily (another adaptation from Lucy Maud Montgomery): after doing this series of pure awesomeness, the director is now happily producing the crap that is Gokujou! Mecha Mote Iinchou, and I’m hoping for this to be the same with Konnichiwa Anne.

This episode really showed that this isn’t going to be among the best of the World Masterpiece Theatre: that fall into the river wasn’t needed. If you look at the other shows of the franchise like Porfy and Les Miserables at this stage, you can see that the drama was only caused by the characters clashing against each other, not these random disasters that happen a bit too conveniently, not to mention that there’s enough clash between the characters to keep this series going.

Having said that, though: I do love this series. There’s one thing that it stays absolutely true to, and that is Anne’s character. Even the lesser WMTs as Ie Naki Ko Remi had rock-solid characters, and there is no way that Konnichiwa Anne is going to be any different, and what this episode did such a wonderful job at is emphasizing how Anne’s name is so important to her, because it’s something that relates her to her parents. This show isn’t going to be the epitome of realism, but it’s still going to be an incredibly charming series. and with that, I guess that it’s also a bit more accessible than usual: if you can stomach the little kids, then there’s always something going on this time. Compare that to Porfy, which pretty much eliminated most of the viewer because hardly anything significantly dramatic happened in the first twelve episodes (which of course also had it’s charms, but it’s obviously not for everyone).