It’s often said that sports anime aren’t really about sports, but about the characters who play them. Not every show in the genre is so dedicated to its cast as to deserve such an assessment, but series like Cross Game, Ping Pong, and this year’s Run With the Wind prove that sometimes it holds true. At the beginning of the fall 2019 season, Hoshiai no Sora looked as though it would join their ranks as a sports anime that put people first and athletics second. Unfortunately, it ended up prioritizing not its characters themselves, but the creation of uniformly damaging family lives for nearly a dozen middle school kids. What’s worse, these difficult situations were often introduced in a given episode, only to disappear for weeks at a time, and in some cases never to be revisited. And when the show finally began to focus on tennis near the end of its run, it paced itself far too quickly, resulting in a wholly unsatisfying finish. Were I to describe Hoshiai no Sora in three words, I’d go with overstuffed, unfocused, and inconclusive.
Hoshiai no Sora – 12 (End)
Let’s start with the elephant in the room, shall we?
Not long after Hoshiai no Sora’s final episode aired, director Kazuki Akane took to Twitter and broke the news that the show had been planned for 24 episodes. That order was reduced to 12 this spring, two years into the show’s production, and rather than restructure the story to fit the new one cour length, Akane decided to keep the story intact and air only its first half. If you’ve seen the final episode, you know that the show ends without a proper resolution for its dozen-plus plot threads, so this decision undoubtedly did some damage on the narrative side of things. With the production having advanced to the animation stage before learning of the slashed episode count, though, it might have been the only option available.
Vinland Saga – 23/24 [Miscalculation/End of the Prologue]
And so we have come to Vinland Saga’s end. It has been a good ride, watching Thorfinn and Askeladd’s journey. Over the last two weeks especially as Canute and Askeladd battle it out with Sweyn over politics. All to try and save a small kingdom named Wales. So without further ado, let’s dive in for the last time.
Now before we go on to the meat of the two episodes, let’s talk about where Vinland goes from here. As the episode 24 title tells you, this is not the end of Vinland’s story. I dare say it is just the beginning, as we are finally done with the prologue. However as of yet, no Season 2 has been announced. Mean Studio Wit has announced they are taking a step back to focus on more original works for the time being. So, what does this mean for the future of Vinland Saga? Well, along with todays episode, a PV was released for the “Story of True Warriors” continuation, which will have more news announced “soon” they say. I have no idea what this is, maybe a movie, maybe an OVA, maybe a Season 2. Regardless, it means more Vinland is in the future, and I couldn’t be happier.
Continue reading “Vinland Saga – 23/24 [Miscalculation/End of the Prologue]”
Chihayafuru S3 – 12 [So the Flower Petals…]
I thought about delaying this post until next week, as there won’t be a new episode on New Year’s Eve, but my 2019 anime backlog is reaching avalanche-like proportions already, so it can’t be delayed any longer. Neither can the Meijin and Queen qualifiers, which are finally underway after last week’s very good table-setting episode. “So the Flower Petals” wasn’t as memorable as that earlier installment, in my opinion, but it does restore one element that the show has been missing for a while: intensity in its karuta matches. Chihayafuru has been keeping the spotlight off Harada-sensei recently, but he’s finally barreled onto center stage, giving us a clearer look at his tenacious playstyle – and I’m quite happy about it.
Continue reading “Chihayafuru S3 – 12 [So the Flower Petals…]”
Neon Genesis Evangelion – 7 [A Human Work] – Throwback Thursday
Hello all to another week of Neon Genesis Evangelion! This week is much more light hearted than the last few, diving more into Misato and Shinji’s relationship. Meanwhile it seems something is a foot as a weapons test goes wrong. So without further ado, lets jump in! And stick around to the end, because I have some important questions about how you would like Throwback Thursday to run moving forward. Onwards!
Starting off, this week saw a bit more of Anno’s weirdness. As cuts come in some strange places, there is a lot of repeated footage and in general it just feels… different. This isn’t necessarily a criticism, as I can see what he was going for. The repeated morning segments do a fine job of setting the time frame of the episode and the pacing of it all. It also gives us a glimpse into Shinji/Misato’s life together, and what their general day to day is like. For those I suppose the question really becomes, are you invested in their life? If yes, then I think it informs a lot about where they are 7 episodes in. If not, then it’s a lot of repeated and wasted time. So suffice to say, I don’t have much a problem with it, but I can see the issue. Continue reading “Neon Genesis Evangelion – 7 [A Human Work] – Throwback Thursday”
Fall 2019 Summary – Week 12
Wooper: I’m all on my lonesome, it seems. We’ve got just two blurbs for this week’s post, both written by yours truly. The holidays are a busy time, after all, and – wait, does this mean my life is the emptiest of all the Star Crossed writers? On that uplifting note, here are a few thoughts on some anime I watched over the past week.
Mugen no Juunin: Immortal 12
This episode felt like a greatest hits compilation to me. How much time was supposed to have passed between the beginning, when Rin encountered Kagehisa, and the end, when they parted ways? It’s very difficult to tell, because each phase of the story was represented by a single scene. Their conversation in the cave near the beginning passed too quickly to quell her vengeful intentions, so the mere fact that they traveled together afterwards felt wrong. If the show had given their partnership another two or three scenes to establish itself, I’d have been okay with it.
Midway through the episode, Rin helped him fend off a band of assassins, and later pleaded with Manji to kill another group of Kagehisa’s pursuers. The overall direction that this takes her character is consistent with what we’ve seen in the past; despite Rin’s anger at the death of her family and her hatred of the man who orchestrated it, the vein of compassion running through her is similarly deep. The issue isn’t the road taken by this episode, then, but the speed at which it traveled. Kagehisa’s illness came on far too quickly, and the appearance of Manji, Magatsu and Makie during the lakeside battle was so sudden that it felt nearly surreal. Of all Immortal’s jam-packed installments thus far, this was the hardest for me to swallow.
Mairimashita! Iruma-kun 12
Looks like we’re on to the next phase of the story: choosing an after-school club. They’re called “Battlers” in the netherworld, and many of them have their eyes on Iruma after his recent dodgeball exploits. Since he’s courted by a handful of club presidents, and countless others are handing out flyers and doing recruitment drives, we get a good look at what sort of extracurricular activities there are to choose from in this version of hell. That’s a fine way to elaborate on your setting, but I feel as though the series missed an opportunity here. At this point, we know that choosing your club has a big impact on your ability to rank up, but we don’t get a sense of what Battler life looks like on a day-to-day basis. The latter is probably more important to Iruma than the former, given the value he places on friendship (as well as his cautious nature). I wish the episode had spent half of its time popping its head into various clubs, then settled on one to really explore during the second portion. It’s a minor quibble, but it did gnaw at me during and after the show this week.
Neon Genesis Evangelion – 6 [Decisive Battle in Tokyo-3/Rei II] – Throwback Thursday
Once again, I am late for this week’s Neon Genesis Evangelion post. It’s becoming a bad habit really, and yet something about Evangelion makes it difficult to write about. I need look no further than this week for proof of that. As here we see a competent governmental body, Rei stepping up to the plate, and Shinji getting in the damn robot. So let’s jump in!
As always, we have to start with the production, and this time I think Evangelion managed to impress. Say what you want about Anno’s… odd tastes in still shots, but the action is great. From the tanks to what is just a giant floating cube, I enjoyed it all. There was even a number of nice environmental animation to go along with the tank or Angel shots. And in general things like melting metal look fantastically fluid. Part of it is no doubt the dated, nostalgic charm that is cell animation. But I don’t think that really takes away from it at all. If I had one complaint though, it would have to be with the odd lighting at times. Like during Rei’s visit to Shinji’s room, I understand the time of day they were shooting for, it just looked weird to me. Minor squibbles aside though, onto the meat!
Hoshiai no Sora – 11
What happened to Hoshiai no Sora? Only a shadow of the remarkable animation it displayed in its first half remains at this point. There are recycled cuts all over this episode, and its general sense of progression reeks of a hurried ending. Half the show’s scripts are saturated with personal and familial drama, while the other half follow the sports anime playbook to the letter. Maki’s dad hasn’t shown his face in six episodes, and its original pay-to-play hook has hardly mattered in the grand scheme of things. At this point, I’m hoping that the cryptic post-credits conversation between Ryouma and his mother will lead to a major development in the finale. The series needs to tie off at least a few of its many unspooled plot threads somehow, and a late-game curveball might be its only chance at a cohesive finish.
Fire Force 21/22 – Those Connected/Brother’s Determination
Welcome to a battle of two families: Vulcan vs Lisa and Shinra vs Sho. These two episodes pair nicely and feature quality fights befitting of a late season shounen. While not big on emotional payoff, Fire Force delivers clues as to the world’s mystery…and a nice hair cut!
Continue reading “Fire Force 21/22 – Those Connected/Brother’s Determination”
Chihayafuru S3 – 11 [Leaving a Hovering Mist Above the Trees and Grass]
So that’s why Harada’s match was omitted last week – Sudo yielded the game before it could even begin. I suppose I ought to be happy that we were given any sort of detail about the East Japan finals, but this “reveal” felt kind of backhanded. Tying Sudo’s concession to his bet with Taichi didn’t affect me the way Chihayafuru desired, because Harada was never the focus of the past few episodes to begin with. If Taichi was indeed instrumental in Harada’s victory, wouldn’t you want to dramatize the moment when he achieved it, even if it proved anticlimactic in the short term?
Ah, forget it. The East/West tournaments are in the past now, and the all-important challenger match is just ahead. This episode was a great stage-setter, in my view, so let’s get into the details.
Continue reading “Chihayafuru S3 – 11 [Leaving a Hovering Mist Above the Trees and Grass]”








































