Now that two episodes have been devoted to giving Takano some background, it’s time for two more episodes of building up, which fill in the final pieces of the mysteries of this show, even though the mystery has long since stopped being a central focus in this show. I suspect that in the next episode, we’ll finally know the only thing I’m still curious about: how did Satoshi die? This episode… it wasn’t really anything special. The only thing I liked was that Satoshi wasn’t as pure as you’d think he was: Satoko was actually a huge burden on the guy. Takano herself was a bit disappointing, though. She feels too much like a stereotypical villain, even after getting background. Tomitake, who was supposed to visit Hinamizawa once every few months shows up damn often, and I’m also quite confused that Satoko, Mion and Rika of four years younger look almost exactly like their older versions. Things become a bit unbelievable when four, perhaps even five years pass and there is no single noticeable difference in appearance for any of the different characters. I would have liked the writers to integrate all these revelations a bit with the storytelling as well. Right now, it just feels that they’re going through a checklist of things that still need explanation. Compare that to the first season, where you knew the exact same that the different characters knew. It would have been so much better if we saw Rika investigate on Takano’s past to find out these things, for example.]]>
The Puzzle Pieces aren’t supposed to be integrated with the main storyline. They literally are just a checklist of scenes you have to play through in order to reach Matsuribayashi-hen in the games.
I can understand that it does feel like a bit of an info dump, though.
And Ryukishi purposefully kept the characters looking the same in order to cast doubt upon their actual ages. Shmion and Keiichi are either 14 or 17, and Satoko and Rika are either 9 or 12 (maybe 13). Nobody knows.
I’m surprised you didn’t like this episode a little more than that. I thought it was pretty damn good — best in the story arc so far, by quite a bit. Can’t wait to see what happens next!
-Tom
This series really has been the only consistant high point this year, it’s not as good as the actual game but it’s still sooo much better than the rest of others. The only downpoint has been the episode set in the future. Thou I will admit that it’ll be nice to be back with the main characters next episode. But whether she’s a sterotypical villain or not this chapter really was needed.