Fumetsu no Anata e – 8-9 [Monster Brothers/Deep Memories]

These new episodes of Fumetsu no Anata e? They’re not good.

 

Last week, I said that I’d figured out my relationship with this show as a viewer. Now I’ve got to iron out my relationship with it as a blogger. Going forward, I’ll write about Fumetsu no Anata e whenever I want – no more weekly or biweekly posts just because that’s our standard format. The series just isn’t built to be scrutinized at regular intervals, as these episodes prove. It’s too workmanlike in its approach to adaptation, resulting in strange tonal issues and thematic muteness capable of killing entire arcs. After Fushi, Gugu is the most prominent character that Fumetsu has offered thus far, yet his suffering and exploitation barely registered amidst the box-ticking of these episodes. When he learned that his employer took advantage of his life-threatening injury to sew an alcohol-fermenting organ into his body, his response was to quit his job and look for work elsewhere. Makes sense, right? What kind of song do you think should accompany such a horrifying discovery? If you went with anything except “soothing folk tune,” congratulations, you have more musical sense than the director of Fumetsu no Anata e.

The way Gugu left was bizarre, as well. A wide shot of his hasty departure was immediately followed by a pan over to a sleeping Fushi, who wearily scratched himself before shutting his eyes again. Shouldn’t we be sticking with Gugu in this situation? Watching him run, encumbered by the mask that his personal Frankenstein gave to him? Hearing his thoughts of anger, betrayal, and disgust? It occurs to me that I had a similar issue with March’s character in the previous story – that the show never dug deeply into her sadness – so maybe this will end up as water under the bridge after Gugu bites the big one. Still, it feels like outside of its tentpole episodes, Fumetsu consistently misses opportunities to vivify the emotional lives of its characters. That’s in keeping with the series of softballs it lobbed throughout the rest of these two weeks, too. His stopover at his new employer’s house barely even registered in my brain thanks to its brevity and predictability, and all the mockery and fear he inspired in others felt ripped from a forgotten youkai-themed series from the 90s.

Then there are all the parallels and contrasts packed into these two episodes, which may be their biggest disappointments. Gugu experiments with Fushi’s regenerative abilities, then realizes he was experimented on himself. Gugu most appreciates Fushi’s monstrous transformation after he embraces his own disfigurement. Gugu, who was abandoned by his mother and father, resents Rean for complaining about her overprotective parents. Rean wears Gugu’s helmet to avoid being seen by others, as he’s had to do since his accident. Each of these ideas are effective in isolation, but when grouped in such tight proximity they blunt each other’s impact. It’s like reading CliffsNotes instead of the novel they condense. If you’re anything like me, you did that more than once during high school, and while it helps you complete your assignments, you feel terribly unsatisfied afterwards. That’s the sensation I got from these two episodes, which ended with Gugu deciding to return to the Booze Man’s house because he’d “lost interest in his own circumstances.” Who can blame the guy? I’ve lost interest in them, too.

Looks like we’ve got round two of the Fushi vs. Wood Monster fight coming up this Monday, but it may be a while before I have anything more to say about this series. The next time Fumetsu comes out with a heater of an episode, you can be sure that I’ll be typing away in some corner of the world. Until then, however, I’m content to let these posts lie.

5 thoughts on “Fumetsu no Anata e – 8-9 [Monster Brothers/Deep Memories]

  1. Ouch. Actually I have a similar attitude towards Tokyo Revengers, which is turning out almost identical in being totally perfunctory and workmanlike in its adaptation approach leading to those same tonal and thematic issues that you’re having with To Your Eternity. It’s strange that the most recent episode has this big, impactful gang fight that was being built up and yet I feel totally nothing from it, especially in comparison with the manga.

  2. Yeah…having read the manga for Fumetsu, the manga actually addresses all of your complaints with it tenfold. I wonder why the anime is leaving out these important character beats? I mean, if you want to develop your characters and flesh them out, they need to have their reactions to the events going on to them or around them shown in detail. That kind of stuff makes people care about them as characters. Leaving them out just makes them feel like ciphers, and Gugu’s my favorite character in the entire manga!

    1. If White Fox had worked on Fumetsu, you’d get fewer cuts and those characters would be developed. I know White Fox has its share of problems, but you can’t fault White Fox for not trying to be faithful to the source material.

  3. Soooooo, with the series now at the halfway point with its 10th episode, what are you thoughts on that one, and this adaptation so far?

Leave a Reply