I am not happy. To say I was disappointed in this episode would be an understatement. I am, to be frank, angry. So much so that I have to admit something that I really don’t want to admit. For you see from what has been shown of the second cour so far I would deem it weak. Not bad per say but not what I have come to expect after the quality of the first cour. The story has been padded and the events that should have large impact have been lesser than they should. More importantly there is a lack of action in the second cour when the first cour at least let loose every now and then. I have begun to fear that the fan titled “Unlimited Budget works” may in fact be running low on the budget. I notice more that they are avoiding showing action and in this episode there is points where art is sacrificed for movement in the action sequences causing It to look off. I hope this is just them saving for the finale because if the budget really is running short then this is the worst possible time for it. We are reaching the finale of UBW which is pretty action packed. This really is the time to bring out all the stops and make this mind blowing, otherwise it will be a disappointing finale. Though admittedly on a rewatch my mind has changed. I am still disappointed that there’s more exposition than action, that the song Emiya only played for 30 seconds(There better be a full version) and that the end of the fight didn’t bring me the joy it would but it isn’t bad. I think this is a matter were my expectations prevented me from enjoying what I got. But here’s the odd thing, I believe that Studio Deen did this scene better in the Unlimited Bladeworks movie.
Yes, in that movie the meaning behind what they were saying was lost but the exhilaration of the fight from the visual novel was there. More importantly, they were fighting while talking which is likely how this would go down. In terms of presentation, Ufotables version is a debate whereas Studio Deens was a brawl. Ufotables version may get across the meaning behind the scene(Though fans say otherwise. But honestly I don’t think everything needs to be spelled out to get the point across. Actually considering what has been shown, I think anyone would get the point seeing as it’s been hammered down to into them to the level where it cannot be ignored) but arguable Deen got the impact which I would deem more important. I couldn’t care less if the fight was less accurate to the visual novel or not, it was fun to watch and damn satisfying. More so than the anti-climatic Ufotable version.
The second half of the episode was all about Gilgamesh cluing in Saber and the rest about the contents of the grail and what he plans for it. It was long, rather tedious and pretty much the worst way to present this information. Infodumping on characters should be a last resort for shows and can only really work if you can work it like the exposition master, Gen. This really shows that Gilgamesh for all his character in Fate/Zero will not get much in Fate/Stay Night. The Fate route is likely the best end for him but here he’s just the last endboss. Kirei is treated in a similar manner but at least gets his much needed development from Heavens Feel. UBW is mostly Gilgamesh’s most active role in Fate/Stay Night as his role in Heavens Feel is minor so sadly this is really all he gets. Many claim that despite him saying he was not affected by the grail that it still managed to corrupt him a little as the Gilgamesh in Fate/Stay Night seems like a different man from how he was in Fate/Zero. His goal of destroying mankind is rather by the numbers and him putting up with Shinji trying to pathetically lord over him without destroying him is a mystery in itself. Speaking of which, congratulations Shinji! You are finally useful for once in your life. Now that Gilgamesh has shoved the grail core inside of you and it’s turned you into something more fitting of your nature. His Akira-like transformation was both disgusting and strangely pleasing. A Shinji in agony is a Shinji that can be loved. We have three episodes left I think(I could be wrong on that, but I hope not. There isn’t enough materiel for more than that.) and the stage for the finale is set. The next looks to be the cooldown period and the return of the CG dolphins that are joked about at every chance. Well it’s not as if the real version from the visual novel is any less stupid. Lets see next time as, in the words of the next episode preview, Rin gives up her most precious thing.(Wink wink, nudge nudge)
Too much talk. Not enough fight.
Thank you for the TLDR version.
I, and maybe quite a lot of people, have to disagree with this review. I always feel that the fight between Shirou and Archer was more on a philosophical side than the actual physical fight. Ufotable did really well to represent that with a lot of symbolism in the episode.
For example; when Shirou realized that he cannot and will not save everyone but he will try his best to realize that dream,his final rush by Shirou had the sky change the color signify his overcoming Archer’s cynical believe and accept UBW as his own.
To be honest I never expected this scene to be fight heavy, because that is not the point of the scene. It is about showing how Shirou determination overcame and reminded Archer of the beauty of the path he took and the path Shirou will spend his life follow.
Screw crappy symbolism. We want action.
“info-dumping” is such an apt word here.
I am a person who has watched anime for a long time.
I have also played a metric ton of video games.
So I understand why most shows/movies based on games blow chunks.
I have never played the fate games.
So from my perspective you may be correct about why you think it is “bad” now.
I think it is at least equal to fate zero and far superior to stay night.
I also think it is one of if not the best anime currently airing.
But I only speak from my perspective.
And just to add the kicker… I do not mind talking.
I don’t mind talking, but holy crap! We’ve had almost 100 minutes throughout the series rehashing this same argument about Shirou’s ideals and the worst part is you know in advance based on the genre that it’s all meaningless. It’s not going to change his mind or alter his actions. You could’ve condensed that whole “duel” scene into a single episode of debate instead of dragging it out over and over.
On the other hand, I didn’t really mind Gilga’s infodump at the end. Yes, I knew all that info from F/Z, but it was at least new to the characters in UBW. And while I wish Saber and Shirou would’ve had better reactions, the dialogue was meaningful and contributes to the advancement of the story.
The scenes with Lancer, Rin, and Kirei have been great and I wish Lancer had a bigger role. But it’s a shame we only got glimpses of them amongst Archer’s long-winded monologuing.