In Praise of 2019’s Short Anime

Happy New Year, everyone! With 2019 in the history books and another season of anime in danger of beginning any day now, it’s easy to get swept up in the current of what’s, well, current. The volume of modern anime production is so high that it’s difficult to keep up, even if you attempt to watch only the good stuff. That’s why, before another landslide of First Impressions arrives to bury us all, I’d like to talk briefly about four anime series that you may have missed during the past year – all of them shorts. Short series are among the first to be discounted in the AOTY conversation, but several of these shows will be appearing on my year-end ballot (fair warning to my fellow writers), and I’d recommend checking out whichever one most appeals to you. All of that said, let’s start with my favorite of the bunch: Rilakkuma and Kaoru.

Continue reading “In Praise of 2019’s Short Anime”

Fall 2019 Summary – Week 13

Wooper: We’re back with another weekly roundup – the last of the year, and perhaps for the foreseeable future. I restarted this column because I found the fall season to be particularly diverse, with lots of worthy shows that weren’t receiving regular coverage. Not all of them remained in our good graces, of course, but this format gave us a fun and easy way to heap both praise and criticism on whatever series we felt like discussing each week. Will winter 2020 be similarly inspiring? We’ll need a few weeks before making that judgment.

First Impressions for the new season are slated to begin a week from now, and our yearly awards post will go live around January 20th. Those are our priorities at the moment – if these weekly summaries do return, it won’t be before that second date. They could reappear in spring, or summer, or not at all. We’ll see what the future holds! Until then, for the final time in 2019, here are some thoughts on what we’ve been watching this week.

No Guns Life 12

Amun: No Guns Life 1-10 were a solid string of excellent episodes. 11 and 12 just took a wildly different turn; I’m not saying they were bad by any means, just that they could have been episodes 3 and 4, and I think it would have made more sense in the overall flow (Apparently there are 24 episodes, but I’m judging this as the first half) That being said, 11 and 12 represented a stand-alone story that served to introduce some characters seen in the OP – I got some real GiTS vibes here. Also, this was quite a well-done car chase scene and some unexpected fanservice. Despite the rather odd midseason redirection, NGL has been superb this whole season. Engaging characters, crisp storylines (11 and 12 notwithstanding), and a beautiful Unreal engine rendered world give NGL a winning combination. To me, this is the future of below-blockbuster tier shows: put the effort into character designs and fight animations and let the computers handle the annoying backgrounds.

Hi Score Girl II – 09

Mario: After spending time with these kids from primary school up to their high school, it’s kinda sad to see it all end. The airport scene wraps up Oono and Haruo’s romance nicely, albeit a tad bit repetitively. We’ve seen this airport scene before, we have seen this situation where Oono gets further away from Haruo before, and we all have seen how Haruo, staying behind, improves himself to become worthy of Oono before. Yet it couldn’t have ended in any other way. The same goes for Hidaka’s role. She’s a supporting character at heart and here she knocks some sense into Haruo even at the cost of losing him forever. Yet she remains such a fantastic character. And that is the core strength of Hi Score Girl – even with all its love for arcade games, it’s all the characters that I find myself thinking about long after the credits roll.

Continue reading “Fall 2019 Summary – Week 13”

Vinland Saga Anime Review – 90/100

There are only a handful of manga out there that I believe to be masterpieces. Works such as Berserk, Vagabond and Monster. That come to define a time in manga history, such as Berserk. That are perfect in their execution like Monster, or are a work of art in every panel like Vagabond. Fewer still are the manga that get anime adaptations worthy of their legacy. We need look no further than the recent Berserk anime adaptations for evidence of that. However, I believe that Vinland Saga, written by Makoto Yukimura of Planetes fame and adapted by Wit Studio has gotten, just that. An adaptation that captures the beauty and story of the original peace. That not only adapts it faithfully, but also designed specifically for an anime’s format. Changing what needs to be changed for the new medium, without losing much of the original work.

So onward friends, for honor and glory! The review awaits!

(Disclaimer: I am working to make 50 the new “average”. 70 is not an average score people. 70 is above average. Also this review contains minor spoilers in song names and such. Carry on.) Continue reading “Vinland Saga Anime Review – 90/100”

Hoshiai no Sora Review – 60/100

It’s often said that sports anime aren’t really about sports, but about the characters who play them. Not every show in the genre is so dedicated to its cast as to deserve such an assessment, but series like Cross Game, Ping Pong, and this year’s Run With the Wind prove that sometimes it holds true. At the beginning of the fall 2019 season, Hoshiai no Sora looked as though it would join their ranks as a sports anime that put people first and athletics second. Unfortunately, it ended up prioritizing not its characters themselves, but the creation of uniformly damaging family lives for nearly a dozen middle school kids. What’s worse, these difficult situations were often introduced in a given episode, only to disappear for weeks at a time, and in some cases never to be revisited. And when the show finally began to focus on tennis near the end of its run, it paced itself far too quickly, resulting in a wholly unsatisfying finish. Were I to describe Hoshiai no Sora in three words, I’d go with overstuffed, unfocused, and inconclusive.

Continue reading “Hoshiai no Sora Review – 60/100”

Fall 2019 Summary – Week 12

Wooper: I’m all on my lonesome, it seems. We’ve got just two blurbs for this week’s post, both written by yours truly. The holidays are a busy time, after all, and – wait, does this mean my life is the emptiest of all the Star Crossed writers? On that uplifting note, here are a few thoughts on some anime I watched over the past week.

Mugen no Juunin: Immortal 12

This episode felt like a greatest hits compilation to me. How much time was supposed to have passed between the beginning, when Rin encountered Kagehisa, and the end, when they parted ways? It’s very difficult to tell, because each phase of the story was represented by a single scene. Their conversation in the cave near the beginning passed too quickly to quell her vengeful intentions, so the mere fact that they traveled together afterwards felt wrong. If the show had given their partnership another two or three scenes to establish itself, I’d have been okay with it.

Midway through the episode, Rin helped him fend off a band of assassins, and later pleaded with Manji to kill another group of Kagehisa’s pursuers. The overall direction that this takes her character is consistent with what we’ve seen in the past; despite Rin’s anger at the death of her family and her hatred of the man who orchestrated it, the vein of compassion running through her is similarly deep. The issue isn’t the road taken by this episode, then, but the speed at which it traveled. Kagehisa’s illness came on far too quickly, and the appearance of Manji, Magatsu and Makie during the lakeside battle was so sudden that it felt nearly surreal. Of all Immortal’s jam-packed installments thus far, this was the hardest for me to swallow.

Mairimashita! Iruma-kun 12

Looks like we’re on to the next phase of the story: choosing an after-school club. They’re called “Battlers” in the netherworld, and many of them have their eyes on Iruma after his recent dodgeball exploits. Since he’s courted by a handful of club presidents, and countless others are handing out flyers and doing recruitment drives, we get a good look at what sort of extracurricular activities there are to choose from in this version of hell. That’s a fine way to elaborate on your setting, but I feel as though the series missed an opportunity here. At this point, we know that choosing your club has a big impact on your ability to rank up, but we don’t get a sense of what Battler life looks like on a day-to-day basis. The latter is probably more important to Iruma than the former, given the value he places on friendship (as well as his cautious nature). I wish the episode had spent half of its time popping its head into various clubs, then settled on one to really explore during the second portion. It’s a minor quibble, but it did gnaw at me during and after the show this week.

Dr.STONE Anime Review – 71/100

There are few genres more ubiquitous than Battle Anime. From classics like One Piece and Naruto to the modern like Kimetsu no Yaiba and Black Clover, they are everywhere. Constantly trying to one up or explore the idea in new ways. As a consequence of this, a sub-genre began to appear, cleverly called “Non-Battle” Battle Anime by Super Eyepatch Wolf. In these kinds of anime, it rare for a conflict to be physical in nature. Whether it be cooking in Food Wars or gambling in Ultimate Survivor Kaiji, a punch is rarely thrown. Dr.STONE by TMS Entertainment however takes this one step further, removing the battle portion entirely, unless you count battles with nature herself. And it is here, in the survival and science rather than physical combat, in a celebration of what it means to be human, that Dr.STONE excels.

Without further ado, it’s time to get into the review.

(Disclaimer: I am working to make 50 the new “average”. 70 is not an average score people. 70 is above average. Also this review contains minor spoilers. Carry on.) Continue reading “Dr.STONE Anime Review – 71/100”

Fall 2019 Summary – Week 11

Wooper: There are just a couple of these posts left to be published before we proceed to a new decade and a new season. I rebooted this column because Fall 2019’s offerings seemed like a stronger-than-average bunch, but I don’t know if I’ll feel the same about this upcoming winter. I might keep it going, or another writer might take up the mantle, or it might disappear until another bounteous crop of shows surfaces deeper into 2020. That decision is still weeks away, however. For now, here are some thoughts about some presently-airing, rapidly-concluding anime from this fall season.

Assassins Pride 10

Amun: Unexpected show discussion alert! Assassins Pride initially faltered in the low-stakes Hogwarts mini-arc but has picked up steam….and randomly bounced between locations. I think the settings of this show really make it interesting – the characters are okay, but ultimately one dimensional. What I really love is the crater, the candlestick, and now this spooky library. The giant spider fight was underwhelming, but a nice try. The biggest takeaway is how improved future backgrounds will be for anime – freeing up the animators to work on characters, fights, etc. As for this show, I get the feeling there will be a lot of political intrigue, then a rushed finale here in the near future.

Mugen no Juunin: Immortal 11

Wooper: After last week’s ‘blink and you’ll miss it’ approach to conflict between sword schools, episode 11 narrowed the show’s lens to focus on a fight between two men. Neither Magatsu nor Shira can boast Hyakurin’s complexity, but what they lack in charisma and backstory they make up for with stamina. They’ve got sufficient stamina, in fact, to survive the numerous fatal wounds that they inflict on each other, which made the whole battle feel rather implausible. Most people who pass the time by watching a blood-soaked seinen about an immortal swordsman aren’t bothered about realism, though, and neither was I. The episode moves along at a good clip, never spending too long on dialogue-driven pit stops before launching back into the action. The background art was as pretty as ever, especially during Manji’s temporary farewell to Magatsu in the forest near the start. The swordplay looked much nicer than usual, as well – probably the best since Makie’s spotlight near the series’ beginning. I’m sure that manga readers are unhappy with one aspect of this episode or another, but I can find few things to criticize.

Continue reading “Fall 2019 Summary – Week 11”

Winter 2020 Season Preview

Lenlo: A new site, a new season, and the first Season Preview on our new domain. Auspicious. Unlike the last season though, which was filled to the brim with sequels, there are surprisingly few this Winter. Though the ones we do have are high profile, such as the 4th season of Haikyuu!! or the third season of Railgun. Not to be outdone, the new adaptations have some up and coming manga such as Runway de Waratte or recently ended classics like Dorohedoro. And none of this is even mentioning the movies such as Made in Abyss’s sequel movie, or the series continuing from last season such as My Hero Academia.

Suffice to say, there’s a lot worth taking a peek at here if you have the time. And if not? Well, that’s why the 5 of us are here. To do our best to give you the scoop on everything anime for Winter 2020. So go ahead, take a look, and if you see anything you like make sure to let us know by voting in the poll below. I can tell you right now, I at least don’t know what I am going to cover yet, so you would help me immensely. Without further ado, in we go.

This poll is no longer accepting votes

What will you be watching from the Winter 2020 season?

ALREADY AIRED

Plunderer

Studio: GEEKTOYS
Director: Hiroyuki Kanbe
Series composition: Masashi Suzuki
Source: Manga

Amun: Plunderer made the ambitious move of releasing not one, but two episodes early to try and drum up some interest and get ahead of the pack. However…they forgot to make an even halfway decent anime. From the studio that brought you Hensuki, which exceeded the absolute dog-tier (anyone who watched it understands) expectations, comes an absolute travesty of a first episode (I’m not watching the second). The premise is actually decent enough – everyone is counting something of vital importance. When this count hits 0, you go to hell – but the count can also go up, so you try and maximize it to avoid dying. Nice premise, how hard can that be to do right?

Apparently, pretty hard. We have the obvious lecher with a heart of gold (of course) with the naive on-a-quest girl, who also has her number in her inner thigh. Of course. Assisted, invariably, by the H-cup barkeep. Alright. Throw in an obvious small time baddie trying to take advantage of naive girl, when lecher comes and saves the day and is super powered….okay, you know how this goes. The problem isn’t so much we’ve seen it before…it’s that all the wrong lessons were learned from shows like Gintama or…whatever else they were watching (One Piece maybe?). This isn’t self-aware or humorous, it doesn’t even attempt plot foreplay – this episode reminds me of Sacred Beasts from two seasons ago, but at least that had a quarter-way interesting heroine. All this rant to say – this is lukewarm garbage to be avoided.

Continue reading “Winter 2020 Season Preview”

Fall 2019 Summary – Week 10

Wooper: With the Winter 2020 preview under construction, and piles of anime to cram before AOTY season arrives, it’s sometimes a miracle these blurbs are written at all. Still, fall has been good to us in terms of variety, so it’s only fair that we repay the favor. Here are our weekly thoughts on the shows that didn’t make the blogging rotation.

No Guns Life 9

Amun: NGL had a bit of a quieter week – I’m surprised to see the transition to another arc. I’m assuming this will be the final arc of the cour plus cliffhanger for the eventual second season (I think it’s done pretty well, so I’m hopeful). Necessary new character introductions, bust size joke, and some Juzo trauma for the Beruhumahumahuma executive – all perfectly serviceable as a setup for the big finale.

Kabukichou Sherlock 9

Wooper: I’ve lost my patience with this show. Irene’s abrupt death and Kirisaki Jack’s utterly forgettable appearances aren’t the final straw, but they’re pretty close to it. I know that Irene is very likely alive, and it might not even be Jack under the mask, but the show ought to imbue these sorts of deceptions with more weight. When a Sherlock-themed show ends on a cliffhanger that questions Moriarty’s involvement in Irene Adler’s murder, and it can’t even bring you to care about the answer, that’s when you know the whole thing is a wash. Watson’s whining about his lack of usefulness to Sherlock was pitiful, as well, unless it was some metacommentary on his irrelevance to the plot as as whole. And can somebody explain the purpose of the swoopy-haired detective’s bungling romance subplot? The girl is in it for the money one moment, then making things official the next, and riding him in bed two scenes after that. The only way this show can recover is if she ends up being Kirisaki Jack herself.

Continue reading “Fall 2019 Summary – Week 10”

Fall 2019 Summary – Week 9

Wooper: Even as much of the West plunges into the madness of the holiday season, Japan keeps pumping out the good stuff week after week. Mario and Amun are still high on their favorites of the season, but one of my early frontrunners might not survive as part of this column much longer if it keeps slipping each week. That’s alright, though – our attention will soon shift to season previews, first impressions, and AOTY discussion. For now, though, here are some thoughts on a few seasonal shows we’ve been digging!

Hi Score Girl II 6

Mario: It all comes down to this. After Haruo x Hidaka match, after Oono x Hidaka challenge, it’s fitting that the final showdown between Oono and Haruo is going to end it once and for all. It’s also very fitting that this final match will be a SFII tournament in Osaka, when Haruo won but utterly felt that he didn’t deserve it. It takes witnessing Hidaka hugging Haruo for Oono to strengthen her resolve regarding Haruo, and it takes seeing Oono’s sad expression for Haruo to be honest with his feelings. Despite all the teases, Haruo has a good number of good people who are behind his back, but ultimately it’s between the main players now. The stakes are higher than ever (even without Haruo knowing it, they’re high for him as well). I also really enjoy the way Oono’s sister behaves when she finds out about Oono leaving soon. She’s the most outspoken character of this cast but we can sense a lot of feelings flowing through her at that time: guilt that she dumped all the responsibility on her sister, the sadness on Haruo’s behalf, her own sadness as well. It’s hard not to root for them all (and maybe scream at Oono’s parents for being dickheads. :))

Mairimashita! Iruma-kun 9

Wooper: Ever since Iruma acquired the Ring of Solomon, there’s been a question of how his character could evolve without falling back on its all-powerful magic. This episode answered that question with a training arc dedicated to dodgeball, of all things. Rather than present Iruma with an obstacle that would require a magical solution, it created a clever mythology for “execution cannonball,” a modern version of an archaic contest once held by demons. Even though the game is essentially a human one, Iruma still struggles to master it due to his skill at dodging things. So we watch as he dodges, and dodges, and dodges, then finally catches a ball in his practice sessions – and that’s the majority of the episode. Apart from that fun initial concept, the actual meat of the thing is overcooked and unseasoned. I much prefer this show when it’s in comedy mode, instead of worrying about Iruma’s rank at school, but his conversation with Ameri last week hinted at a shift toward the latter. We’ll see rather the show can achieve a good balance to close out 2019.

Continue reading “Fall 2019 Summary – Week 9”