Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 02

The stage is set, the actors are in place and the curtain is rising. So I can say this episode’s title was certainly apt. Unfortunately this week we have no bombastic fight scene to ogle and instead we get a heavy dose of info dumping. This is not the most exciting of episodes but the ending scene does promise to make up for the lack of action. Truly, UFOtable made a wise choice when deciding to make the first two episodes an hour long, as to get to this point in what could have been five weeks with regular twenty four minute episodes would have been a terrible slow start. Though I did think that the show was more suited to a hour long episode format but well that may be me moaning about my weekly fate/stay night being all the shorter. Well c’est la vie.

Servants, mana, the holy grail war…if you are familiar with any part of the canon then these things is something you already know about. Making this the least interesting episode for fate fans. We all know this episode needs to happen and we can thank UFOtable for getting it out of the way. Not to say there won’t be info dumping later in the series but at least it will not be quite as excessive. Let me summarize this episode, Shirou is taken inside his house to be told about the holy grail war. Then he is taken to the church where Kotomine Kirei tells him more about the holy grail war and Shirou makes the choice to fight. That is the episode in a nutshell. Like I said, not the most eventful of episodes.

One of the commenters in the previous episode review made a statement about Tohsaka Rin being a character that panders to the audience. On reading this I felt he was exaggerating a bit but upon seeing Rin berate herself for failing to summon Saber by vigorously scratching her hair, lying on the floor and then wiggling her butt in the air, I must be forced to admit that maybe this man has a point. This reaction was much more subdued in the source and I can’t see any reason for it to be this overdone other than to titillate the character fanbase. I for one would appreciate these kinds of reactions being less evident in the rest of the series. Shirou also didn’t come looking the best seeing as a lot of his lines in this episode was mainly him taking what has already been said and repeating it in the form of a question or simply asking questions. This became better as he was talking to Kirei but overall it doesn’t make his character seem all that smart when all other characters are lecturing him. And yes Kirei, definitely the highlight of the episode. Now having accepted his nature in the prequel anime he has now become a lot more, shall we say, cheerful? His antagonistic quips and small manipulations making a large infodump a lot more interesting. Things like trying to push Shirou into killing masters while omitting the information that he doesn’t need to, help get across the information better rather than simply laying it out straight. And while this may be personal preference speaking, I have always loved the tone of his voice. While his english voice actor has done a great job presenting the character, one thing I feel he could never match was the Japanese voice actors sound. A voice that is grandiose, yet hinted with malicious intent. Truly the voice of a man such as Kotomine Kirei.

The art of the series remains excellent and while the animation this week does not require much there is enough movement to show these are not motionless dolls and actually human beings talking. The environments are looking great with the fog and desolate atmosphere which should lend well to the next episode. Finally this helping ends with the formerly shown magical girl coming to attack our heroes so next episode will be quite the treat. That I promise.

Grisaia no Kajitsu – 02

The grisaia visual novel was by no means perfect. In fact if I was to summarize it as concisely as possible I would deem it a mixed bag. Some great moments but quite a number of bad storytelling decisions. Still there was hope for this anime adaption. After all the Steins Gate adaption managed to cut out the weaker elements of the source material and managed to make it shine through highlighting its strengths. I hoped that with the right hands the same could be done with this.

At least…that’s what I hoped. The result has so far been not up to my lowest expectations. The art is decent, the animation fairly bare and the treatment of the story abysmal. Notable examples being the use of chibi character models for two scenes in this particular episode. This was a cheap money saving tactic for the visual novel and it is disappointing to see it used once again in the anime adaption. I spotted a large amount of still frames and face close ups. When there is movement it’s good, in particular Yumiyo’s attack at the beginning of the episode looked like it had some weight in it. Despite the minimal amount of time the protagonist has spent at the school the anime makes it seem like he has been there a lot longer. In the words of a friend who watched this with me “It feels like I just skipped a huge chunk of the story.” Which was exactly my sentiment. To us the viewer Yuuji has been there for only a day. Yet all the girls are acting overly familiar. To top it off this episode ended with a montage of how these girls entered this school. Such an event would normally be placed at the middle or end if a series. Many of these girls have barely had ten minutes screentime. One hasn’t even had five. Is the viewer supposed to be sentimental about characters we barely know? Transitions between scenes are jarring, often switching randomly without warning. One scene switched to a flashback and it took me a full five seconds to figure out it was a flashback. Even then I wasn’t certain I was correct. But most importantly the pacing is far too fast. Dialogue felt like the characters were on fast forward, trying to get the scene over with.

The saving graces are the moments which turn harem tropes on there head and a rather unusual protagonist for this kind of genre. You have no idea how refreshing it is to have a harem lead who does not light up red at the slightest hint of female intimacy. He may not be the most expressive or interesting character but I take this any day over the standard wooden plank we get. If harems had more protagonists like this then at least we could have some fun with this old tired genre.

To top it off I have heard unconfirmed information about this being a one cour(12/13 episodes) anime. This would certainly explain the rushed editing. Let me say this, with one cour this will not end well. A shame as recently a kickstarter was made to bring the Grisaia visual novels to the west. Something which I do approve of. But if this anime is supposed to show us why we should check out the visual novel then it better get its act together. Fast.

Some Quick First Impressions: Grisaia no Kajitsu, Trinity Seven and Inou Battle wa Nichijou-kei no Naka de

Grisaia no Kajitsu

Short Synopsis: Our protagonist joins a school that has five troubled girls in attendance.

AidanAK47’s impression: Grisaia has all the elements to cause many to write it off as a typical harem anime. Protagonist who only wants a ordinary life? Check. Joins school with several female beauties? Check. Panty shots? Sigh…check. The usual line-up of haremettes such as the loli, tsundere, maid and kuudere? Double check. However beneath the shallow premise lies something a little more interesting. For one, despite our main character edging close to gary sue, it is delightful to see him brush off harem clichés with cold indifference. Any man that walks in accidentally on a girl changing and says “Who called me a stripper? Its not my birthday today.” has my respect. Plus props to the girl for not shouting baka, not resorting to abusing the man who only walked in because of her negligence to lock the bloody door and even laughing it off. The end of the episode also hints at darker things to come. I for one hope it proves to be something more than harem show no.56302.

Potential: 60%

Trinity Seven

Short Synopsis: Our protagonist goes to hogwarts.

AidanAK47’s impression: Nothing new to see here. While it did have some mild interest going in the beginning with the black sun, soon it used every cliche in the book. School setting, protagonist who happens to have huge potential for power, haremettes, accidently grope, the walk in while girl is changing/bathing… You have seen it a hundred times before and likely a hundred times again. I say if you need a time waster this season it’s not a bad show to settle on but frankly there are shows more worth your time. I would also like to point out that trinity refers to three, yet there is seven people in this so called trinity. So the title is contradictory.

Potential: 25%

Inou Battle wa Nichijou-kei no Naka de

Short Synopsis: Our protagonist is in a club with cute girls with superpowers.

AidanAK47’s impression: You would never guess this was studio trigger. Yes, that studio trigger. The makers of Kill la Kill, little witch academia and worked on Gurren Lagann. Here is their next show and it’s about a guy in a club with cute girls. Alright I wouldn’t give Trigger grief for this one. If it’s one thing that trigger needs, it’s money. Kill la Kill suffered because of a lacking budget so I certainly cannot condemn these men for making something for the money. That said having watched it I can say that I didn’t hate it. I am ashamed to admit that I may have even enjoyed it. That said I thought that one of the main draws of this club stories is how the club gathered and was created. However here the club is already created and our members gathered. On top of that they all seem to be romantically interested the protagonist. I honestly question how they will fill up the rest of the season when they have pretty much cut out the starting material. Well all I can say is that I hope this makes a ton of money, so trigger can put it forward to something more worthwhile. (Like say….Lucifer and the biscuit hammer, hint hint.)

Potential: 35%

Fate/Stay Night Unlimited Bladeworks – 01

First things first. To those of you coming into this anime from the prequel anime Fate/zero I suggest that you do not expect another fate/zero. Fate/zero and fate/stay night are two different beasts. If I was truly pushed I would say that Fate/zero is the more mature series whereas Fate/stay night was the more shounen series. However that does not mean that the latter is weaker than the former. Both have their strengths and weaknesses and it’s best to enjoy what you get rather than lament what you don’t. If you intend to experience this as a different kind of story then you can get the most enjoyment out of it.

So to recap. This is not a remake of Studio Deens 2006 Fate/stay night. The original visual novel had three routes. These routes could be considered alternate tellings of the same story. Same characters, same setup but a different way that things turned out. The routes are named Fate, unlimited bladeworks and heavens feel. This is the unlimited bladeworks route so our main heroine has changed from Saber to Rin. To provide a simpler explanation, think of the 2006 anime as Full Metal Alchemist and this new anime is Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood. Both may start the same but end up completely different stories. Our episode begins to retell the events leading to the climax of the prologue. However this time from the perspective of Shirou Emiya, our main protagonist. (Yes I am sure many hoped it would stay with Rin but bear with me.) The first thirty minutes deal with Shirou’s daily life of helping fixing broken objects at school, cooking at home, and small touches foreshadowing the things to come. To new viewers this may not be very interesting but to those of you coming from the visual novel or prequel anime, the slight subtleties are bound to interest you. Then upon witnessing two figures fighting at school our main is quickly stabbed in the heart and left for dead. But thanks to mystery helper from last episode manages to heal and walk back home. But his previous killer is coming back to finish the job.

Lets talk about Shirou for a minute. He’s been called a sexist pig, a stupid idiot and a outright annoying useless whiner. To those of you coming from the source we know these things are simply not true. This is a misconception spawned by a lacking adaption and…by some questionable things in the source itself. Withhold your gasps and outcries my kin. This is coming from someone who is currently re-reading the source. And yes there are some rare questionable “stay in the kitchen” moments that no amount of monologuing justify. This moments are only present in the fate route however and seeing his actions in the other two make Shirou being sexist not add up. The reason I bring this up is because gentlemen this is UFOtables greatest hurdle. Of this anime the main, if not most important element is to fix this years held misconception of Shirou. Because this is his story and if you do not care for this character then all the pretty animation in the world won’t get you invested.

How are they doing so far? I say, fair. The fact is that a lot of his character is in monologues and those are things which do not mix well with a visual focused medium such as this. There are moments where they are attempts to turn his inner monologues in dialogue though I argue that the result is a little bit unnatural. Considering what was omitted from the visual novel I say one of the most important ones was the battle between Lancer and Shirou. This was bypassed pretty fast. A pity as it was a strong character moment. Speaking of Lancer I am fond of the business like manner displayed when killing Shirou. In another anime this would have some psycho hyena with a half moon smile yelling how awesome killing is and how he can’t wait to get home to drown kittens, punch babies and worship satan. But with Lancer there is none of this. Just a bored sense of duty firmly disappointed in having to perform the act. It’s nice and shows that he is not someone without a heart. His second attack was also notable. At first trying to end the kids life quickly but seeing him put up a fight giving him a decent chance to defend himself. I like that. And do I even need to speak on the Lancer vs Saber fight? It’s UFOtable level animation, quite frankly it speaks for itself.

Lastly, one thing I find rather irritating is that if you judged this based on the opening then you would assume that Saber is once again the main heroine. She isn’t. Sabers had her story and she shouldn’t be so prominently featured in someone elses. But once again Type moon seems reluctant to change their poster girl. By the way I know my kin well so I will say this. Guys keep the talk of future events and lore out of the comments. No spoilers, even if they are asked for. Because gentlemen we didn’t need someone at our side shouting how awesome this series is to recognise it’s value. Let them see for themselves.