It still surprises me with how much this series can get away. I mean, this must have been originally intended as some sort of sell-out, and yet: the ED of this episode is purely instrumental. It was a really good ED, but it in no way promotes AKB48 as an idol group. Really: whoever was behind that idea: I really admire the balls it must have taken to go with this.
Add that to the different cast members openly criticizing the system for AKB0048, on top of this episode showing how this business can mentally break down these girls from the stress they face. These are some very surprising liberties, and with this, I really hope for a second season for this series. especially since this episode came with a bunch of twists that can only be good with some extra episodes.
In a 1-cour series, claiming on the 12th episode that you’re going to say goodbye means an aftermath. In a 2-cour series, it means character development end evolution. Same for that new pet thingy that appeared at the end of the episode.
Also, how many “hard work and guts”-tropes is Nagisa going to subvert anyway? I mean, they go on this heroic quest to save her father, but he doesn’t want to be rescued. She gets her chance to perform in the center of the stage, and breaks down. The motivational speech she gets in this episode about not giving up doesn’t change anything: she still lost, but it made her face the fact that she did rather than completely turning the tables. She still had to see everyone work extra hard to make up for her.
Does that make her a bad character? Here’s the thing: I usually hate characters who don’t do anything, because they’re completely pointless. Nagisa is different, though: her uselessness has a point, and she also has a character; I especially liked that she changed after meeting her father and decided to not inconvenience her mother.
Rating: Excellent
You forgot a final thing to add to the list of pointlessness. They didn’t even end up performing the song she was to lead as they had to abandon the concert!
There was also the blonde girl who the boy she liked has basically moved on so her becoming an idol has lost her a potential relationship. Really the whole show screams that the idol industry sucks.