Now this is more like it. Well as they say, better late than never and this was at least the best moment to bring back the quality. All I ask is where this was three episodes ago which it could have made all the difference in the world. Admittedly this episode has made me a lot less bitter about this second season as at least now it has a great finale. At first my expectations were set to low as once again dialogue was giving more presence with Gilgamesh rehashing what Archer was saying to Shirou having a good but unnecessary monologue. But what followed has been everything I have been waiting for in this adaption. It’s true that Shirou was showing a level of power that was beyond a human and that by realistic standards he should have been shredded to bits. (There are some explanations for this like UBW being able to copy the abilities of the owners welder but it’s only feasible at best.) But I honestly don’t care as it was exhilarating, beautiful and exciting being the fight I was long promised but not delivered till now. I am sad that other fights up till now were not given this treatment and I hold a vain hope that maybe Ufotable will add more to them for the blu-ray discs. For a fan it’s a real treat as we have, not one, not two, not three but four new remixes of songs from the visual novel. (There may be others that I missed) Those being Last Strength, Sword of promised victory, New Dawn and Disillusions piano version with Emiya played again at the climax for absolute perfection. Disillusions piano version is as emotionally sombre as ever and I feel that Sword of promised victory was done better here than Yuki’s Fate/Zero version where the choirs drained some of the impact of the song. Nostalgia may be making a fool out of me in how I am getting so excited about these songs but more than anything this show was made for the fans and this is fanservice I can get behind.
Previously I stated that even though Archer used UBW twice that it doesn’t really explain his strange mana levels. This episode shows exactly why that is the case as Archer shows up for one last attack on both Gilgamesh and the grail. Whether it is in the visual novel or the anime this moment has always been a pretty poor deus ex machina because the only explanation for Archer still being alive is independent action. He faked his death? Can’t be done, servants can sense other servants, except for Assassin who has presence concealment, so even if he tried to fake his death both Gilgamesh and Saber should have noticed he was still around. Independent action? This only allows the servant to stay in the world two days and that estimate is based on avoiding fighting and using the absolute minimum of mana, which Archer was clearly not doing. The best excuse for this that I have gotten was that while he was Castors servant, he stockpiled on mana but this has issues as well. There is also an argument that Archer was brought back as a counter guardian seeing as the world was in peril and while I like this explaination I am afraid it doesn’t work out either as if Archer was summoned as a counter guardian then he wouldn’t remember the events of this holy grail war. All and all Archer coming back for the final fight should be impossible but while it is cheap, at least it gives Rin a moment to say a last goodbye to him and wrap up his arc. Whether Archer used UBW once or twice doesn’t matter as this moment is still not justified and this is one of the things that shows that the source material wasn’t perfect. Archers final smile at least showed that Shirou wasn’t the only one who gained something from all this, at least now he has regained some of the optimism that put him on this path in the first place despite what awaits him.
This final fight does make me recall the fact that I only started liking Gilgamesh once I read Fate/zero as it is true that he and Kirei are fairly one dimensional in this route and the Fate route. But this fight does show the genius of Gilgameshs character. Put frankly, Gilgamesh is unbeatable. He is such a powerful opponent that if he went all out he could win the Holy Grail war within a day or even less. In terms of ability he trumps everyone so it is just so perfectly suitable that his only weakness lies in his personality. Gilgamesh is so egotistical that to go all out against someone who he seems not worty is an insult of the highest caliber. Throughout this fight he was constantly handicapping himself what from the fact that he didn’t wear armour, his limited usage of Gate of Babylon and his reluctance to use Ea. One moment I adore is the point where Shirou is about to land the killing blow and Gilgamesh is preparing to draw Ea but before he grips the handle, he hesitates. It was that moment of hesitation that sealed his doom and what truly made this a win for Shirou. Archer may have stuck the killing blow but Shirou made him take him seriously as a fighter and as the king said so himself, the moment he does that would be the the moment he truly lost. The story is essentially complete now and all that remains is the epilogue but I wonder just what will they put in to fill a episode. At worse it will just be them going to school and time wasting and at best it could elaborate on just what awaits Rin and Shirou in the future. Well let’s just wrap it up and start the long excruciating wait for Heavens Feel.
When Shi- I mean Archer smiled, I almost gagged. The animators are just trying so hard to make the ending of the series heartwarming, lol.
I love how Shirou gained more power and abilities in this one episode than the whole of the two-part series. Convenient isn’t it, writers?
You realize that this story is from the original game yeah?
The animators aren’t doing anything, it was written that kitschy, and I think Fate is from the 80s or 90s, back then that was considered normal I think.
About shirous powers, it seems crazy but it was kinda explained.
The mana he received from Rin allowed him to do all the projection stuff and I think his fighting skills were explained from receiving archers experience and his ability allowing him to use swords to part of their originals full-potential.
These might be sketchy, but honestly most superpowers in this series are, and in my opinion his actual sword fighting was impressive but not unfeasible for a normal guy. So yeah, the mass projections are crazy but they spent an episode explaining that so it’s not that off.
If anything Gilgamesh seems to bearly put any resistance…
80s? Fate/stay night (the original VN) was released in 2004.
If all of this did actually come from the VN then I think Ufotable did a commendable job adapting, and certainly a wonderful job animating it. No blame there.
Come on, give him a break. It’s actually less heartwarming and more depressing when you take into account that after this he will be forced to play hitman for hire for all eterity. It was in the visual novel as well so it wasn’t the animaters idea.
The explainations are there but I too think they could have showed Shirous power up more gradually. But well then I just think, who cares, it’s awesome. That’s all that matters.
Nasuverse is full of ranks. Archer has Independant Action skill Rank idk, but enough to act out his role as the plot demands :p
Same for concealment, though it’s true that Assassin is a class of his own in this.
Mana levels got little to do with Servants staying around masterless. Servants can eat souls to replenish mana, so if they’re not squeamish enough mana will never EVER be a problem. Other ways to replenish mana are probably possible too.
Gil, isn’t really a proper servant since Fate/Zero events either. He has a body and can live normally, but, while not elaborated in UBW, has a power source (nasty stuff too) to allow him the use of his Gate of Babylon.